Review of UBL 2.2

[Christoph Karich <Christoph.Karich@msg-systems.com>]

Dear all,

 

as part of the EU e-SENS eTendering Pilot, I would like to submit the following comments regarding the UBL 2.2 Public Review:

 

-          cbc:HashAlgorithmMethod: should rather be an identifier or code value, since hash algorithms are usually refered to by URI References as specified by W3C XMLEnc. Maybe introducing HashAlgorithmMehtodIdentifier or HahsAlgorithmMethodCode alongside the now given textual representation might be a feasible solution.   

-          Tender/cac:TenderedProject: current cardinality is 1..*; however since the tendered project is solely identified/referenced by the Tender/cbc:ContractFolderID the cac:TenderedProject currently serves only as a vessel for the lotIdentifier within the project (atleast for the syntax mapping done by CEN/BII). So the cardinality should rather be 0..* instead.

 

Best regards,

Christoph Kairch

 

 

--

Christoph Karich
Lead Business Consultant
GB O – Public Sector Business Consulting

msg systems ag
Wittestraße 30
13509 Berlin

Tel.: +49 89 96101 0
Mobil: +49 172 6868 134
E-Mail: christoph.karich@msg-systems.com

http://www.msg-systems.com

Sitz der Gesellschaft: Robert-Bürkle-Str. 1, D-85737 Ismaning/München
Vorstand: Hans Zehetmaier (Vorsitzender), Dr. Stephan Frohnhoff, Bernhard Lang, 
Roland Roudny, Jens Stäcker, Dr. Dirk Taubner
Aufsichtsratsvorsitzender: Dr. Christian Hofer
Handelsregister: Amtsgericht München, HRB 140 149