Re: [ubl-lcsc] draft 12 etc models

[Tim McGrath <tmcgrath@portcomm.com.au>]

thanks for your diligence.  i think i can explain our thinking on these 
matters.

Between draft 11 and draft 12, we realised that the naming rule for DEN 
was not correctly implemented.

The actual rule is...

a. where proerty term noun is the same as representation term only use 
the representation term.
b. property term qualifiers are separated from the rest of the property 
term by a whitespace character (" ")
c. property term possessives (were called adjectives) are separated from 
the property term noun by an underscore ("_")

so...

Despatch Advice. Globally Unique. Identifier

- means "Globally Unique" is the only part of the property term used, we 
only use the representation term "Identifier" in the DEN

Despatch Advice. Document_Status. Code

- means that the property term possesive "Document" is joined by the 
underscore to the property term noun "Status" and the representation 
term is 'Code".

Despatch Advice. Despatch Advice _Type. Code
- the property term possessive is actually the two words "Despatch Advice".  this is not too elegant and probably should have just been called Type. Code (the property term possessive is an overkill)


Address. Additional Street. Name

- this one has the lot!  the property term qualifier "Additional" is 
joined by a space to the rest of the property term.  the property term 
possessive "Street" would be joined to the property term noun "Name" by 
an underscore, except that this is the same as the Representation Term 
and so is dropped.

Michael Dill wrote:

>Hello,
>
>After a review of the 'old' models I do not understand many changes in den
>Excelfiles. Examples:
>
>UBL-DespatchAdvice-1.0-alpha-draft-12.xls row 5: The term 'Globally Unique'
>is an entry in the Property Qualifier column. In the DEN it appears as
>Property Term.
>- GUID	Despatch Advice. Globally Unique. Identifier		Despatch Advice
>Globally Unique		Identifier		Identifier
>
>UBL-DespatchAdvice-1.0-alpha-draft-12.xls row 7: The DEN is not complete.
>- DocumentStatusCode	Despatch Advice. Document_Status. Code		Despatch Advice
>Document	Status		Code
>
>UBL-DespatchAdvice-1.0-alpha-draft-12.xls row 8: There is no Property
>Qualifier. That's why the term 'Despatch Advice _Type' should be changed
>into 'Despatch Advice Type', i.e. without any underscore.
>- DespatchAdviceTypeCode	Despatch Advice. Despatch Advice _Type. Code
>Despatch Advice		Despatch Advice 	Type		Code
>
>UBL-Reusable-1.0-alpha-draft-12.xls row 8: The term 'Additional' is used as
>Property Qualifier. That's why the DEN should be changed into 'Address.
>Additional_ Street. Name'.
>- AdditionalStreetName	Address. Additional Street. Name		Address	Additional
>Street	Name		Name
>
>Please apologize if these remarks are obsolet.
>Best regards,
>Michael Dill
>
>
>To unsubscribe from this mailing list (and be removed from the roster of the OASIS TC), go to http://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/ubl-lcsc/members/leave_workgroup.php.
>
>  
>

-- 
regards
tim mcgrath
phone: +618 93352228  
postal: po box 1289   fremantle    western australia 6160