[ubl-lcsc] Codelist listID, etc

["Stephen Green" <stephen_green@seventhproject.co.uk>]

Hi

I don't have posting access to CLSC so please would

someone forward this to their list too. Thanks.

In preparing the updated sample instances for draft 3
with a new RT Schema (as previously posted) I've found
that it is now possible to add the code supplementary
components, e.g.

<cbt:PaymentMeansTypeCode

         listID="UNTDID-TRED-4451"

         listVersionID="D03A"

         listAgencyName="UNECE">ZZZ</cbt:PaymentMeansTypeCode>

In this example I have used for listID the ID value format

I found in some old CBL archives "UNTDID-TRED-4451".

Do we agree (or need to agree) on this format?
This could equally have been "tred4451", "tred 4451",
"TRED-4451", etc.

Do we not need a controlled vocabulary or guidelines for

expressing such values?

I was nervous about adding a listAgencyID because it is
yet another ID or Code needing a controlled vocabulary
(or highly specialised knowledge of existing standards)
or code list (perhaps the CC folk should have called these
things listAgencyCode, etc and provided codelists).
But a second reason was that I could not easily find a list
of these agency ID's, merely anecdotal evidence that
the ID for ISO is '6'.

Tim, we really should, I think, define all these in the
Codelist Catalogue for all the codes we wish people
to use, at least. Please note my updated Codelist
Catalogue version 1 draft 3 in the latest model posted for
these further edits.

All the best

 

Stephen Green