SV: [ubl-psc] UBL 2.0 Update proposals

["Peter Borresen" <plb@itst.dk>]

Hi Martin

Then, maybe you can help me anwering a question: How can you tell whether
nothing has changed from the Order to the OrderRepesponse?  When are two
instances of theese to different messages alike? 

An acknowledging ordering flow must end with an OrderResponseSimple. To my
mind OrderResponseSimple is not a simple version of orderResponse, but a
document, that ends the ordering process.

Putting an AcceptIndication into OrderResponse will redefine both documents.
I am not sure we agreed on this in NES (becaused we sticked to the
orderResponseSimple), but I am sure that I managed to convince Mark that
There was a need for OrderResponseSimple, or orderResponse Stupid, as he
called it.

Let's say that we have an AcceptIndicator in OrderReponse. If that one is set
to true and one of the lines has changed. What does it means? Or opposite if
the AcceptIndicator is false and nothing has changed? Accepting or rejecting
the Order as a whole is a diffenrent scope than the OrderResponse, which
really is an OrderLineRespose Sample.

Kind regards

Peter

-----Oprindelig meddelelse-----
Fra: Martin Forsberg [mailto:martin.forsberg@ecru.se] 
Sendt: 22. november 2007 14:23
Til: Peter Borresen; 'Tim McGrath'; ubl-psc@lists.oasis-open.org
Emne: RE: [ubl-psc] UBL 2.0 Update proposals

Hi Peter,

I must disagree with your disagreement :)

*****
PLB: I disagree with this because, it conflicts with the use of
OrderResponse. OrderReponse is allways used when something in the order is
not accepted, otherwise the OrderResponseSimple (OrderAccept + OrderReject´as
one document) is used. 
*****

You can make a full accept with OrderResponse (no changes on any lines or
accept with changes). If the seller substitutes an item, based on the buyers
proposal, then I would say the OrderResponse is an acceptance. Or does it say
somewhere that only OrderResponseSimple can be used for full accept/reject? I
know we've had this discussionen in NES, but I can't remember the outcome. 

/Martin