UBL Criteria

[Oriol Bausą <oriol@invinet.org>]

Hi Fulya, 

Following the point about criteria in Allerod, I'd like to know if we can share the components in CPFR and in CODICE about this in order to see if we can align and create a unique Criteria and then further qualify it.

Tendering has two criteria classes, AwardingCriteria and EvaluationCriteria.

TypeCode

Awarding Criteria. Type. Code

Awarding Criteria

Type

Type

Code

Code. Type

0..1

BBIE

Code that defines the awarding criteria.

Description

Awarding Criteria. Description. Text

Awarding Criteria

Description

Description

Text

Text. Type

1..n

BBIE

Textual description of the criteria.

WeightNumeric

Awarding Criteria. Weight. Numeric

Awarding Criteria

Weight

Weight

Numeric

Numeric. Type

1

BBIE

Specific weight assigned to this awarding criteria.

Weight

Awarding Criteria.  Weight. Text

Awarding Criteria

Weight

Weight

Text

Text. Type

0..n

BBIE

Textual description of  the weight for this awarding criteria.

Expression

Awarding Criteria.  Expression. Text

Awarding Criteria

Expression

Expression

Text

Text. Type

0..n

BBIE

Textual description of  the mathematical expression that would evaluate the criteria.

MinimumQuantity

Awarding Criteria. Minimum. Quantity

Awarding Criteria

Minimum

Minimum

Quantity

Quantity. Type

0..1

BBIE

Minimum quantity for a specified or expected deliverable.

MaximumQuantity

Awarding Criteria. Maximum. Quantity

Awarding Criteria

Maximum

Maximum

Quantity

Quantity. Type

0..1

BBIE

Maximum quantity for a specified or expected deliverable.

MinimumAmount

Awarding Criteria. Minimum. Amount

Awarding Criteria

Minimum

Minimum

Amount

Amount. Type

0..1

BBIE

Minimum amount for a specified or expected deliverable.

MaximumAmount

Awarding Criteria. Maximum. Amount

Awarding Criteria

Maximum

Maximum

Amount

Amount. Type

0..1

BBIE

Maximum amount for a specified or expected deliverable.

SubordinateAwardingCriteria

Awarding Criteria. Subordinate_ Awarding Criteria. Awarding Criteria

Awarding Criteria

Subordinate

Awarding Criteria

Awarding Criteria

Awarding Criteria

0..n

ASBIE

Subcriteria for this awarding criteria

and 

EvaluationCriteria

Evaluation Criteria. Details

Evaluation Criteria

0..0

ABIE

Criteria that should be required to a tenderer in order to evaluate its capacity.

TypeCode

Evaluation Criteria. Type. Code

Evaluation Criteria

Type

Type

Code

Code. Type

0..1

BBIE

Code that defines the financial or technical criteria, such as total revenue, qualified staff.

Description

Evaluation Criteria. Description. Text

Evaluation Criteria

Description

Description

Text

Text. Type

0..n

BBIE

Textual description of the criteria.

ThresholdAmount

Evaluation Criteria. Threshold. Amount

Evaluation Criteria

Threshold

Threshold

Amount

Amount. Type

0..1

BBIE

Estimated threshold amount for that criteria in this tendering process.

ThresholdQuantity

Evaluation Criteria. Threshold. Quantity

Evaluation Criteria

Threshold

Threshold

Quantity

Quantity. Type

0..1

BBIE

Estimated threshold quantity for that criteria in this tendering process.

ExpressionCode

Evaluation Criteria. Expression. Code

Evaluation Criteria

Expression

Expression

Code

Code. Type

0..n

BBIE

Code describing the expression that would evaluate the criteria.

DurationPeriod

Evaluation Criteria. Duration_ Period. Period

Evaluation Criteria

Duration

Period

Period

Period

0..1

ASBIE

Period during which the evaluation criteria should be positive.

SuggestedEvidenceElement

Evaluation Criteria. Suggested_ Evidence Element. Evidence Element

Evaluation Criteria

Suggested

Evidence Element

Evidence Element

Evidence Element

0..n

ASBIE

Evidence that is suggested to be used to fulfil the criteria.

We need to align these two components, but I'd like to know how does your criteria component looks like in order to see if we can align all of them

Regards, 

Oriol