<!-- MHonArc v2.5.0b2 -->
<!--X-Subject: Re: [ubl&#45;security] New draft (UBL&#45;XAdES&#45;Profile 1.0&#45;20100321) -->
<!--X-From-R13: =?vfb&#45;8859&#45;1?C?Aevby_Pnhf=S0_Brevf?= <bevbyNvaivarg.bet> -->
<!--X-Date: 5 Apr 2010 10:07:25 &#45;0000 -->
<!--X-Message-Id: 21444F8C&#45;4731&#45;4946&#45;B19E&#45;B7&#69;9&#54;1&#49;38CA8&#64;&#x69;&#110;v&#105;&#x6e;et.&#111;&#x72;g -->
<!--X-Content-Type: multipart/mixed -->
<!--X-Reference: 001101ca6ce7$be05d960$3a118c20$@&#x69;&#x6e;za&#x40;alba&#108;i&#97;.c&#x6f;m -->
<!--X-Reference: 273DACE4&#45;A786&#45;40E6&#45;98A8&#45;FFE&#x38;13ED&#x37;&#x35;23&#64;s&#x74;u&#x64;&#105;o&#x63;a&#x63;&#99;ia.&#x63;om -->
<!--X-Reference: 4&#x42;1&#x32;6&#x36;&#x30;&#52;.&#x36;&#x30;&#51;080&#x30;&#x40;jave&#115;&#116;&#x2e;c&#x6f;m -->
<!--X-Reference: 4B&#49;3&#68;&#x37;&#x42;E.&#x39;&#48;&#50;&#48;&#x31;&#64;&#x6a;&#x61;v&#101;st.&#x63;om -->
<!--X-Reference: &#x37;.0&#46;&#49;.&#x30;.&#x32;&#46;&#50;&#48;&#48;&#57;1130214&#53;&#x32;&#x31;.&#48;278&#x62;eb8&#64;&#x77;&#104;&#x65;&#x72;&#x65;&#115;&#109;&#x79;&#x6d;ai&#x6c;ser&#118;er&#x2e;&#99;&#x6f;m -->
<!--X-Reference: 042398CB&#45;7D2B&#45;4F4A&#45;AFAF&#45;5E28&#54;&#x41;&#x42;445&#x46;&#x42;&#64;&#73;N&#x56;&#x49;&#78;E&#84;.&#x4f;R&#71; -->
<!--X-Reference: 4&#66;&#49;&#x34;&#52;5B&#x38;&#46;2&#48;&#x35;0&#x39;&#x40;ja&#x76;e&#115;&#116;&#46;com -->
<!--X-Reference: &#x37;.&#48;&#46;&#49;.&#x30;.&#50;&#46;2&#48;&#48;9&#x31;&#x32;0&#49;&#48;7&#x31;05&#50;&#46;0&#50;55&#x63;&#x36;90&#x40;wh&#x65;&#114;es&#109;&#121;&#109;a&#105;lse&#x72;v&#101;&#x72;.co&#109; -->
<!--X-Reference: 4&#x42;&#x31;5&#54;&#55;1&#52;.&#x38;0&#49;&#48;4&#x40;javes&#116;.&#99;o&#109; -->
<!--X-Reference: &#x37;&#x2e;0&#x2e;1.0&#x2e;2&#x2e;2&#48;&#48;&#x39;&#x31;&#x32;&#x30;&#49;1&#x35;&#53;&#50;4&#x31;&#46;0&#50;&#x35;&#x30;&#56;030&#x40;&#119;he&#x72;e&#x73;m&#x79;&#x6d;&#97;&#x69;&#108;&#115;e&#x72;&#x76;&#x65;r&#46;&#99;&#111;m -->
<!--X-Reference: &#x34;&#x42;1594&#x30;8&#46;4&#48;10&#56;&#x30;5&#64;&#106;&#x61;&#x76;e&#115;t.&#x63;&#x6f;m -->
<!--X-Reference: 72AB53E1&#45;031F&#45;4688&#45;9B65&#45;&#56;&#65;&#x42;&#x37;C6&#x45;&#x46;&#x38;9&#x39;&#x38;&#64;&#x73;&#x74;&#117;&#100;ioc&#97;cc&#x69;&#x61;&#x2e;c&#111;&#x6d; -->
<!--X-Reference: &#x37;.0&#x2e;1.0.&#x32;&#46;2009&#49;2&#x30;&#50;&#x30;92&#52;&#48;7.026&#55;4&#x32;d&#x30;&#64;&#x77;&#104;&#101;&#114;&#101;&#115;m&#x79;mail&#115;&#101;&#x72;&#118;&#101;&#x72;.c&#x6f;&#109; -->
<!--X-Reference: AD8D28F5&#45;97C7&#45;4FA0&#45;A8A3&#45;&#x32;159&#x32;&#x46;7EC&#50;&#x46;C&#x40;&#x49;N&#x56;I&#x4e;&#x45;T&#46;O&#82;G -->
<!--X-Reference: 81D1F562&#45;3332&#45;4F27&#45;89C0&#45;4B4F4&#x44;&#x33;&#x45;&#x36;3&#49;C&#64;&#x73;&#116;&#117;d&#x69;oc&#97;&#99;&#x63;i&#x61;&#46;&#x63;om -->
<!--X-Reference: 7&#46;0.&#x31;.0.&#x32;.&#x32;&#48;&#48;&#x39;&#49;&#50;03&#50;12&#57;&#x30;&#48;&#x2e;02&#55;&#102;0&#97;&#x32;8&#64;wh&#x65;r&#x65;&#x73;&#x6d;&#x79;&#x6d;&#x61;il&#x73;&#101;rve&#114;&#x2e;&#x63;&#x6f;&#x6d; -->
<!--X-Reference: A1EA23DF&#45;ECE2&#45;4CC6&#45;A197&#45;&#68;&#52;F&#54;&#x31;&#x30;&#52;32F&#53;2&#64;&#x73;&#116;&#x75;&#100;&#x69;&#111;&#x63;&#97;&#99;&#x63;&#x69;&#97;&#46;c&#111;m -->
<!--X-Reference: 7.&#48;.&#x31;&#x2e;0.&#x32;.2&#48;0&#57;&#x31;22&#51;&#48;&#x38;&#x34;&#x35;&#52;5.&#x30;2&#x38;2e&#50;b8&#64;w&#x68;&#101;&#114;esmy&#109;&#x61;&#x69;l&#x73;er&#118;&#x65;&#x72;.c&#x6f;&#x6d; -->
<!--X-Reference: 2DCB4AB1&#45;8A0A&#45;43BC&#45;8686&#45;&#52;3&#48;3E&#48;&#x39;&#57;5B5E&#x40;INVI&#78;ET.ORG -->
<!--X-Reference: 7.0.1.0.2.20091223101951.02543d08@wheresmymailserve r.com -->
<!--X-Reference: 4B&#x33;&#x33;&#54;&#65;&#56;&#x30;&#46;10&#x32;0105&#x40;&#106;a&#x76;&#101;s&#116;.&#x63;&#111;&#109; -->
<!--X-Reference: 3D9F543E&#45;5D49&#45;4C7C&#45;8056&#45;&#66;&#x46;53&#x39;&#66;&#65;&#52;9&#x38;&#56;2&#64;&#x73;&#x74;&#117;d&#x69;o&#x63;&#x61;&#x63;c&#105;&#97;&#46;&#99;o&#109; -->
<!--X-Reference: FE86553A&#45;CF35&#45;49F4&#45;91E6&#45;9A&#x37;&#x32;1&#x45;7&#x32;&#x42;&#x38;&#x39;F&#64;i&#110;vi&#x6e;&#101;t.&#x6f;&#114;g -->
<!--X-Reference: D589D2A4&#45;B6CB&#45;4AA9&#45;90DE&#45;0&#51;&#x37;&#50;D&#57;&#56;&#70;4&#55;&#x36;6&#64;&#115;&#x74;&#117;&#x64;i&#x6f;&#99;&#x61;&#x63;&#x63;&#x69;a&#46;c&#111;&#x6d; -->
<!--X-Reference: CB781908&#45;E194&#45;482F&#45;8BD4&#45;8EF44&#49;&#x37;B&#55;A&#x33;C&#64;inv&#x69;ne&#116;.&#x6f;rg -->
<!--X-Reference: CE93E982&#45;E050&#45;4270&#45;9C54&#45;&#x41;&#x45;&#x30;&#66;&#54;B&#56;1FD&#70;9&#x40;st&#117;&#x64;ioca&#x63;cia.c&#111;&#x6d; -->
<!--X-Reference: &#x37;&#x2e;0&#46;&#x31;&#46;&#x30;.2.20&#49;&#48;&#48;32021&#x30;4&#49;9.&#48;&#50;61&#98;8&#100;&#56;&#x40;w&#104;e&#114;&#101;&#x73;m&#121;mails&#x65;&#114;&#118;er&#46;c&#x6f;m -->
<!--X-Reference: 086E2F6E&#45;F126&#45;4095&#45;B6B1&#45;&#67;&#53;&#x41;&#x39;9&#51;7&#x39;E3F&#x39;&#64;&#x73;&#116;&#117;d&#105;&#111;cac&#x63;&#105;a&#x2e;co&#x6d; -->
<!--X-Reference: 02CE3D23&#45;C455&#45;40DF&#45;AC31&#45;&#51;4&#66;&#x34;&#x46;4CC9&#57;2&#x42;&#64;stud&#x69;ocac&#99;i&#97;.&#x63;o&#x6d; -->
<!--X-Derived: doc00000.doc -->
<!--X-Head-End-->

<!DOCTYPE HTML PUBLIC "-//W3C//DTD HTML 4.01 Transitional//EN">
<HTML>
<HEAD>
<link rel="stylesheet" href="/css/top.css" type="text/css">
<TITLE>Re: [ubl-security] New draft (UBL-XAdES-Profile 1.0-20100321)</TITLE>
</HEAD>

<BODY>

<div style="padding: 1em; margin: 0 auto 0 auto; text-align: center; width: 400px; font-size: 10pt; background-color: #FFFFFF;"><form name="mmsearch" action="http://markmail.org/search/"><fieldset style="border: 3px solid #FFCC35; color: #3C1A57;"><legend style="font-weight: bold;">OASIS Mailing List Archives</legend>View the OASIS mailing list archive below<br />or browse/search using <a href="http://markmail.org">MarkMail</a>.<div style="float: left; vertical-align: middle;"><input type="text" name="q" size="18" /><br />&nbsp;</div><div style="float: right; vertical-align: middle; text-align: left;"><input type="radio" checked="1" name="q" value="list:org.oasis-open.lists.ubl-security" id="thislist"> <label for="thislist">This list only</label><br /><input type="radio" name="q" value="list:org.oasis-open list:org.xml list:org.ebxml" id="alllists"> <label for="alllists">All OASIS lists</label></div><div style="vertical-align: middle; text-align: center;"><input type="submit" value="Search" style="margin-bottom: 3px;" /><br /><input type="button" onClick="document.mmsearch.elements[1].value=''; document.mmsearch.submit();" value="Browse" /></div><div><strong>Help:</strong> <a href="http://www.oasis-open.org/maillists/guidelines.php#searchingarchives">OASIS Mailing Lists Help</a> | <a href="http://markmail.org/docs/faq.xqy#searchsyntax">MarkMail Help</a></div></fieldset></form></div><H1 class="block">ubl-security message</H1>

<!--X-Body-Begin-->
<!--X-User-Header-->
<!--X-User-Header-End-->
<!--X-TopPNI-->

<p>[Date Prev]
 | [Thread Prev]
 | [<a href="msg00001.html">Thread Next</a>]
 | [<a href="msg00001.html">Date Next</a>]

--

[<A HREF="maillist.html#00000">Date Index</A>]
 | [<A HREF="threads.html#00000">Thread Index</A>]
 | [<a href="/archives/ubl-security/">List Home</a>]</p>

<HR>


<!--X-TopPNI-End-->
<!--X-MsgBody-->
<!--X-Subject-Header-Begin-->

<p><em>Subject</em>: <b>Re: [ubl-security] New draft (UBL-XAdES-Profile 1.0-20100321)</b></p>

<!--X-Subject-Header-End-->
<!--X-Head-of-Message-->
<ul>
<li><em>From</em>: <b>Oriol Bausà Peris &lt;o&#114;&#105;&#111;l&#64;inv&#x69;ne&#116;.o&#x72;g&gt;</b></li>
<li><em>To</em>: Andrea Caccia &lt;&#97;&#110;d&#114;&#101;a&#46;&#x63;a&#x63;ci&#x61;&#64;s&#116;u&#100;&#105;&#111;c&#97;&#99;c&#105;a&#x2e;&#99;&#111;m&gt;</li>
<li><em>Date</em>: Mon, 5 Apr 2010 12:06:34 +0200</li>
</ul>
<!--X-Head-of-Message-End-->
<!--X-Head-Body-Sep-Begin-->
<hr>
<!--X-Head-Body-Sep-End-->
<!--X-Body-of-Message-->
<pre>
Hi Andrea,

We have been working with the document in CODICE and there are some issues that I've tried to arise in the release I am currently attaching to this document.

1) When using enveloped signature, it is not mandatory using a cac:Signature element. You can optionally provide for it, but you are not mandated to do so. This means that you will be able to sign with this profile any kind of UBL document, despite the fact modellers added this structure to the document model. I mean that one thing is the data model of the document, and another thing are the legal provisions that require a signature to be placed there. That's why I recommend to change MUST for MAY when talking about enveloped signataure and cac:Signature element.

2) I think there are some mistakes, talking about enveloping instead of enveloped signatures during the document.

3) I haven't added nothing about this yet, but there is a requirement for unsigned data, a placeholder where people can add stuff after having signed the document. I'll come back to you with this issue later on.

I've made some modifications in the document according to the first two points. I 'd like to get feedback from the other security subgroup members.

Thank you
Oriol
</pre>
<p><a href="doc00000.doc" >UBL-XAdES-Profile 1.0-20100321-ob.doc</a></p>
<pre>


El 26/03/2010, a las 15:16, Andrea Caccia escribió:

&gt; The attached draft is my best effort to consider all issues that come up.
&gt; The version whose filename ends with &quot;RevCtrl&quot; has been done with Word revision control activated so who already read the old version can find quickly the differences.
&gt; I kindly ask all to all to read it carefully as this is hopefully very close to be finalized. If anyone want to comment directly on the document is welcome but on the version without with all the changes already accepted, otherwise it would be very difficult to see the changes.
&gt; I need help especially on XML parts, ad I do not have a very detailed knowledge, there could be some issue. I need also the XPath expression for the Enveloped signatures, as I mentioned early XMLDsig has a specific processing rule for it.
&gt; I look forward to hear from you.
&gt; 
&gt; Andrea
&gt; &lt;UBL-XAdES-Profile 1.0-20100321.doc&gt;&lt;UBL-XAdES-Profile 1.0-20100321+RevCtrl.doc&gt;
&gt; 
&gt; 
&gt; 
&gt; 
&gt; 
&gt; ---------------------------------------------------------------------
&gt; To unsubscribe from this mail list, you must leave the OASIS TC that
&gt; generates this mail.  Follow this link to all your TCs in OASIS at:
&gt; <A  HREF="https://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/portal/my_workgroups.php">https://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/portal/my_workgroups.php</A>

</pre>

<!--X-Body-of-Message-End-->
<!--X-MsgBody-End-->
<!--X-Follow-Ups-->
<hr>
<ul><li><strong>Follow-Ups</strong>:
<ul>
<li><strong><a name="00001" href="msg00001.html">Re: [ubl-security] New draft (UBL-XAdES-Profile 1.0-20100321)</a></strong>
<ul><li><em>From:</em> JAVEST by Roberto Cisternino &lt;ro&#x62;er&#x74;&#111;&#x40;j&#97;v&#101;st.&#x63;&#x6f;&#109;&gt;</li></ul></li>
</ul></li></ul>
<!--X-Follow-Ups-End-->
<!--X-References-->
<!--X-References-End-->
<!--X-BotPNI-->

<HR>

<p>[Date Prev]
 | [Thread Prev]
 | [<a href="msg00001.html">Thread Next</a>]
 | [<a href="msg00001.html">Date Next</a>]

--

[<A HREF="maillist.html#00000">Date Index</A>]
 | [<A HREF="threads.html#00000">Thread Index</A>]
 | [<a href="/archives/ubl-security/">List Home</a>]</p>

<!-- FORM -->

<HR noshade SIZE=4>


<!--X-BotPNI-End-->
<!--X-User-Footer-->
<!--X-User-Footer-End-->

<!-- <P>Powered by <A HREF="http://www.ezmlm.org/">ezmlm-idx</A></p> -->

</BODY>
</HTML>