[Date Prev] | [Thread Prev] | [Thread Next] | [Date Next] -- [Date Index] | [Thread Index] | [List Home]
Subject: Re: [ubl] Minutes of Pacific UBL TC call 7 August 2012
So are we trying to settle on 'Transport' or 'Transportation'? Doesn't this proposal just swap the terms around?
If we cannot easily rationalize to only one term then I suggest we leave them as they are.
On 8/08/12 9:28 PM, Jon Bosak wrote:
We seem to be AGREED that the following changes can be made: COMMON LIBRARY TransportationSegment -> TransportSegment TransportationSegmentType -> TransportSegmentType TransportServiceCode -> TransportationServiceCode TransportServiceCodeType -> TransportationServiceCodeType
DOCUMENT MODELS
UBL-GoodsItemItinerary-2.1 TransportationSegment -> TransportSegment The problem remaining centers around a number of terms containing the substring "TransportService"; this use collides with the adoption of "TransportationService" for what appears to be the same concept in UBL 2.0. In particular, the following proposed changes would involve renaming a document type:UBL-TransportServiceDescription-2.1 -> UBL-TransportationServiceDescription-2.1 TransportServiceDescriptionDocumentReference -> TransportationServiceDescriptionDocumentReference TransportServiceDescriptionRequestDocumentReference -> TransportationServiceDescriptionRequestDocumentReferenceAnd these proposed changes would involve changes to the names of parties:COMMON LIBRARYResponsibleTransportServiceProviderParty -> ResponsibleTransportationServiceProviderParty TransportServiceProviderParty -> TransportationServiceProviderParty TransportServiceProviderRemarks -> TransportationServiceProviderRemarks TransportServiceProviderRemarksType -> TransportationServiceProviderRemarksType TransportServiceProviderResponseDeadlinePeriod -> TransportationServiceProviderResponseDeadlinePeriod TransportServiceProviderSpecialTerms -> TransportationServiceProviderSpecialTerms TransportServiceProviderSpecialTermsType -> TransportationServiceProviderSpecialTermsTypeDOCUMENT MODELS UBL-TransportExecutionPlan-2.1TransportServiceProviderRemarks -> TransportationServiceProviderRemarks TransportServiceProviderParty -> TransportationServiceProviderParty TransportServiceDescriptionDocumentReference -> TransportationServiceDescriptionDocumentReference TransportServiceProviderResponseDeadlinePeriod -> TransportationServiceProviderResponseDeadlinePeriodUBL-TransportExecutionPlanRequest-2.1TransportServiceProviderParty -> TransportationServiceProviderParty TransportServiceDescriptionDocumentReference -> TransportationServiceDescriptionDocumentReference TransportServiceProviderResponseDeadlinePeriod -> TransportationServiceProviderResponseDeadlinePeriodTransportServiceDescription -> TransportationServiceDescription TransportServiceDescriptionType -> TransportationServiceDescriptionType TransportServiceDescriptionRequestDocumentReference -> TransportationServiceDescriptionRequestDocumentReference TransportServiceProviderParty -> TransportationServiceProviderPartyUBL-TransportServiceDescriptionRequest-2.1 -> UBL-TransportationServiceDescriptionRequest-2.1TransportServiceDescriptionRequest -> TransportationServiceDescriptionRequest TransportServiceDescriptionRequestType -> TransportationServiceDescriptionRequestType TransportServiceProviderParty -> TransportationServiceProviderPartyThe argument against making these changes is that they will inconvenience stakeholders that have already begun implementation based on PRD2, despite that fact that PRD2 contains an explicit notice that it is for testing purposes only and should not be used for production and despite that fact that TSC has been making changes and additions to the transportation models until a few weeks ago. The crux of the issue is that the term "Transportation Service" was adopted in UBL 2.0 and that there appears to be no semantic distinction between a Transportation Service and a Transport Service. Absent such a distinction, there is scant justification for using two different terms to refer to the identical concept. ACTION: TSC to consider whether a clear semantic distinction (or, failing that, some operational distinction) can be made between a Transportation Service and a Transport Service, and if so, to produce a clear enunciation of that difference. TC CONCALL SCHEDULE We have tentatively scheduled TC calls through October. Week of 2012.08.06 Regular schedule Week of 2012.08.13 Regular schedule Week of 2012.08.20 Regular schedule Week of 2012.08.27 Regular schedule Week of 2012.09.03 Regular schedule Week of 2012.09.10 Regular schedule Week of 2012.09.17 Regular schedule Week of 2012.09.24 Regular schedule Week of 2012.10.01 Regular schedule Week of 2012.10.08 Regular schedule Week of 2012.10.15 *** CANCELLED *** Week of 2012.10.22 Regular schedule Week of 2012.10.29 Regular schedule Jon Bosak Chair, OASIS UBL TC --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: ubl-unsubscribe@lists.oasis-open.org For additional commands, e-mail: ubl-help@lists.oasis-open.org
begin:vcard fn:Tim McGrath n:McGrath;Tim org:Document Engineering Services email;internet:tim.mcgrath@documentengineeringservices.com title:Managing Director tel;work:+61893352228 tel;home:+61438352228 tel;cell:+61438352228 url:www.documentengineeringservices.com version:2.1 end:vcard
[Date Prev] | [Thread Prev] | [Thread Next] | [Date Next] -- [Date Index] | [Thread Index] | [List Home]