Re: [ubl] TC ACTION: Prepare for discussion of Reusable architecture

["Yukinori Saito" <saito-yukinori@fujielectric.co.jp>]

Hello UBL TC,
I have posted the concrete proposal to UBL TC regarding this subject on May
21, 2005.
I have attached this proposal in this e-mail. Please review this proposal.

I think that the resolution regarding this proposal has the following 3
options.
Please examine this observational comments for UBL TC decision.

1. Option 1: Adopt my proposal completely.
(1) Merit
This architecture is desirable one.
The UBL library will grow up in the near future. For example: Add new
document types like pre-order documents and the three new post-invoice
documents.
The library will be categorized desirably. and UBL users will be easy to
refer the library.
(2) Demerit
This option has considerable influences to the current UBL library. For
example: Change the structures of XML Schema, change the structures of Small
Subset library, and others.
(3) My consideration
This option require some additional resources and working. If the related
UBL members will agree this working, this option will be possible.

2. Option 2: Remain the current Reusable as the current structure like UBL
Core BIEs, but create the new group Reusable BIEs for the additional
document types.
(2) Merit
There is no necessity to change the current Reusable structures.
The UBL users will be easy to understand and reuse the UBL library including
Reusable.
(3) Demerit
This option is not the best solution at the view point of classification of
the UBL library.
(4) My consideration
If almost UBL members will agree this option, this option will be realistic
solution.

3. Option 3: Remain the current Reusable as the current structure, and add
the additional reusable BIEs for the additional document types to the
current Reusable.
(1) Merit
There is no necessity to change the current Reusable structures.
(2) Demerit
As you know, the current UBL Reusable library has 60 ABIEs. The contents has
431 contents (BBIE and ASBIE). This Reusable is huge to handle not only for
UBL Users but also UBL TC members already.
If the additional Reusable contents for the additional document types would
be added to this Reusable library, it would become much troublesome to
handle.
(3) My consideration
This option  is bad selection.

Best Regards,
Yukinori Saito
-------------------------------------------
Yukinori Saito
Fuji Electric Information Service Co., Ltd. (FIS)
e-mail: saito-yukinori@fujielectric.co.jp
Tel: +81-3-5435-7333     Fax: +81-3-5435-7513
------------------------------------------- 


----- Original Message ----- 
From: <jon.bosak@sun.com>
To: <ubl@lists.oasis-open.org>
Sent: Thursday, June 23, 2005 3:13 AM
Subject: [ubl] TC ACTION: Prepare for discussion of Reusable architecture


Hello UBL TC,

Note that we will be resolving the proposed Reusable
architecture in the Atlantic TC call 29 June.  In preparation,
please review the proposal from Yukinori Saito:

      http://lists.oasis-open.org/archives/ubl/200505/msg00079.html

It would be helpful to have preliminary comments on this proposal
registered in email, particularly from members in Asia who may not
be able to attend the Atlantic TC call.

Jon

---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe from this mail list, you must leave the OASIS TC that
generates this mail.  You may a link to this group and all your TCs in OASIS
at:
https://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/portal/my_workgroups.php

--- Begin Message ---

• From: "Yukinori Saito" <saito-yukinori@fujielectric.co.jp>
• To: "UBL TC" <ubl@lists.oasis-open.org>
• Date: Sat, 21 May 2005 16:05:21 +0900

Dear UBL TC members,

According to the decision at UBL TC Hangzhou meeting, I did the following
working regarding restructuring of UBL spreadsheet V1.0.

1. Analysis of the current UBL Reusable V1.0 and restructuring
classification
I have researched and analyzed the current UBL Reusable V1.0.
Then, I have classified ABIEs in the Reusable V1.0 to the restructured
spreadsheet V1.1
I have made the following documents.
(1) Analysis of UBL Reusable Spreadsheet V1.0 and Restructuring of the
Spreadsheet
- This document explains both Analysis method and restructuring method.
(2) Analysis Table of UBL Reusable V1.0 and Classification to V1.1
- This document explains analysis and classifications regarding each ABIE in
Reusable V1.0.

2. Development new spreadsheet V1.1
According to the analysis and classification of Reusable V1.0 described
above, I have made the following spreadsheet V1.1.
These spreadsheets were developed using the recent UBL specifications
'cd-UBL-1.0' at UBL page in OASIS web site.
- UBL-Invoice-1.1.xls
- UBL-CommonProcurementBIEs-1.1.xls
- UBL-CoreBIEs-1.1.xls

According to the analysis, there is no necessity of restructuring the
remaining business documents. e.g.: Order, OrderResponse,
OrderResponseSimple, OrderChange, OrderCancellation, DespatchAdvice,
ReceiptAdvice.

Best Regards,
Yukinori Saito
-------------------------------------------
Yukinori Saito
Fuji Electric Information Service Co., Ltd. (FIS)
e-mail: saito-yukinori@fujielectric.co.jp
Tel: +81-3-5435-7333     Fax: +81-3-5435-7513
------------------------------------------- 

Analysis of UBL Reusable Spreadsheet V1.0 and Restructuring of the spreadsheet.doc

Analysis Table of UBL Reusable V1.0 and Clasification to V1.1.xls

UBL-Invoice-1.1.xls

UBL-CommonnProcurementBIEs-1.1.xls

UBL-CoreBIEs-1.1.xls

--- End Message ---