uddi-spec message
[Date Prev]
| [Thread Prev]
| [Thread Next]
| [Date Next]
--
[Date Index]
| [Thread Index]
| [Elist Home]
Subject: RE: [uddi-spec] AR019 Completed - Update of v2 tModels in prepara tionfor submission of V2 as an OASIS Std.
- From: "Von Riegen, Claus" <claus.von.riegen@sap.com>
- To: 'Luc Clement' <lclement@microsoft.com>, uddi-spec@lists.oasis-open.org
- Date: Thu, 12 Dec 2002 10:21:40 +0100
Title: AR019 Completed - Update of v2 tModels in preparation for submission of V2 as an OASIS Std.
Hi
Luc,
I am
sure that I have read the documents once before, but I now have found
some technical issues (most of them are minor ones) as
follows.
UDDI
Registry tModels
- Section 1.4 (Example of Use) uses the "urn:uddi-org:api_v2" namespace
although it is an example for a UDDI V1 inquiry (should be
"urn:uddi.org:api").
- Section 2.4 (Example of Use): the XML fragment is not valid.
"<businessKey>BK1....</busienssKey>" should be
changed to
"<businessKey>BK1....</businessKey>".
- Section 3.3.1.1 (tModel structure): the tModel description currently
says "This tModel defines the publication API calls for interacting with
the UDDI registry." It should better say "This tModel defines the
publication API calls for interacting with a V1 UDDI
node."
- Section 3.4 (Messages covered) should be numbered 3.3.2 - in analogy to
the other sections.
- Section 3.5 (Example of Use) is then numbered 3.4. Also, the
"<save_binding generic="2.0"
xnkbs="urn:uddi-org:api_v2">" is
inconsistent and makes use of V2 behavior, which is not what the example
should show. A change to "<save_binding generic="1.0"
xmlns="urn:uddi-org:api">" should work.
- Section 4.3.1.1 (tModel structure): the tModel description currently
says "This tModel defines the publication Version 2 API calls for interacting
with the UDDI registry." Since there is not only one
UDDI registry, it should better say "This tModel defines the publication API
calls for interacting with a V2 UDDI
node."
- Section 4.4 (Example of Use) currently says
"The following is a typical addPublisherAssertiions message
..." and should be changed to "The following is a typical
addPublisherAssertions message ...".
- Section 6.3.1.1 (tModel structure): the
tModel description currently says "This tModel defines the taxonomy
maintenance Version 2 API calls for interacting with
the UDDI registry." This should be changed to read "This
tModel defines the taxonomy validation API calls for interacting with a
V2 UDDI node."
Taxonomy tModels
- Section 7 (UDDI OwningBusiness Identifier System): We obviously missed
to update this document when we decided to change the tModel type from
"identifier" to "categorization" as can be seen by section 13.1.2.7
of the UDDI V2.04 API Specification. Thus, the whole section
should be updated by replacing "identifier" with "categorization" and changing
the text accordingly. Further, section 7.3.2 (Valid Values) should be
updated so that it reflects the specified behavior: "The value set of
this taxonomy is the set of businessKeys. It is used to specify that the
businessEntity whose businessKey is the keyValue in a keyedReference "owns"
the tagged tModel. The entity tagged must be a tModel, the referred-to
businessEntity must exist, and it must have been published by the publisher
that publishes the tagged information."
- Section 9 (UDDI Operators Identifier System) should be updated similar
to section 7, since the tModel's type was also changed from "identifier"
to "categorization" and the only valid value is "node" (instead of the
businessKeys of the operators).
Claus
In accordance with our discussion at the 20021203
telecon, Toufic Boubez and I took AR019 (http://oasis-open.org/committees/uddi-spec/doc/process/UDDI-TC-ARList.htm). Our task was to cleanup each of the following v2
tModels:
- UDDI Registry tModels
- UDDI Other Core tModel
- Replication tModels
- Taxonomy tModels
The changes that were made was to add a tModel
structure definition to each of the tModels; correct the overviewURLs of some;
and reconcile the categorization of the tModels with those of the tModel
structure definitions.
This AR has been completed. Draft Word (includes
revision marks) and HTML document versions of the tModels has been posted for
review at the following locations:
- UDDI Registry tModels:
- UDDI Other Core tModel
- Replication tModels
- Taxonomy tModels
Please review and provide comment by close of
business Tue 17 Dec. This is necessary to allow Tom and I to proceed to submit
the "V2 package" to the OASIS board for vote as an OASIS Standard.
Luc Clément
Microsoft
Co-chair, OASIS UDDI Spec
TC
[Date Prev]
| [Thread Prev]
| [Thread Next]
| [Date Next]
--
[Date Index]
| [Thread Index]
| [Elist Home]
Powered by eList eXpress LLC