uddi-spec message
[Date Prev]
| [Thread Prev]
| [Thread Next]
| [Date Next]
--
[Date Index]
| [Thread Index]
| [List Home]
Subject: RE: [uddi-spec] IsReplacedBy TModel comments
- From: Andrew Hately <hately@us.ibm.com>
- To: uddi-spec@lists.oasis-open.org
- Date: Tue, 6 May 2003 14:47:03 -0500
Here are the list of tModels case folded
then hashed that should be updated per CR003 (and the two updates from
CR020). I can either submit as a new CR or update an existing one
and resubmit for consideration.
Also, while working through this exercise,
I noticed that we using the naming convention of "uddi:uddi.org:sortorder:"
for the keys for binarysort and uts-10 and we used the convention "uddi:uddi.org:findqualifier:"
for the keys for caseinsensitivesort, casesensitivesort, sortbynameasc,
sortbynamedesc, sortbydateasc and sortbydatedesc. Should we use a
consistent convention here? I have not changed it in the list below,
but can do so if desired.
11.1.5.2
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:categorization:owningBusiness
Derived V1,V2 format key: uuid:d08ffb57-3e4c-3f9b-a9f7-022b7bdb7d4e
should be
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:categorization:owningbusiness
Derived V1,V2 format key: uuid:f171f5a6-3de7-3a1f-87e4-41d213c1c421
11.1.6.2
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:identifier:isReplacedBy
Derived V1,V2 format key: uuid:54af30ae-9b61-385c-9d1d-ab572e72bff2
should be
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:identifier:isreplacedby
Derived V1,V2 format key: uuid:35b60490-9aea-326b-9097-cfa6d96e97df
11.1.7.2
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:categorization:validatedBy
Derived V1,V2 format key: uuid:82984443-0485-3d17-a934-b0933b3fc2f1
should be
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:categorization:validatedBy
Derived V1,V2 format key: uuid:a96eca99-4267-38d9-85ef-abc56396de63
11.1.8.3
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:categorization:derivedFrom
Derived V1,V2 format key: uuid:0894546b-91ed-37a0-af79-64136fa3f337
should be
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:categorization:derivedfrom
Derived V1,V2 format key: uuid:fced9c64-3d78-31ef-9246-73d94c1d6986
11.2.5.3
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:ownership_transfer_v3
Derived V1, V2 format key: uuid:c68509e9-1e76-345f-8bae-0aef223f9de1
should be (per Change Request 20)
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:v3_ownership_transfer
Derived V1, V2 format key: uuid:e69383a3-07b7-3f5f-b67e-68901e10850c
11.2.6.3
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:node_custody_transfer_v3
Derived V1,V2 format key: uuid:89aa7d66-a871-30fb-b168-bea37c587c11
should be (per Change Request 20)
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:v3_node_custody_transfer
Derived V1,V2 format key: uuid:4d4e1931-1b54-39cb-b165-48ff9f05497d
11.2.7.3
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:v3_valueSetCaching
Derived V1,V2 format key: uuid:fec572e8-500a-3474-a0c2-67964f5dc81b
should be
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:v3_valuesetcaching
Derived V1,V2 format key: uuid:64c892a7-9d17-3d17-85f3-6ad5d2cbb42c
11.2.8.3
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:v3_valueSetValidation
Derived V1,V2 format key: uuid:d1a7a708-fd46-38a5-b60d-6ba9c2d115c2
should be
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:v3_valuesetvalidation
Derived V1,V2 format key: uuid:c5089849-5000-39e5-9944-6ae7bab0628b
11.2.10.3
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:v3_subscriptionListener
Derived V1, V2 format key: uuid:19a5cf6b-1d76-3b70-9e55-a8df186bd4b3
should be
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:v3_subscriptionlistener
Derived V1, V2 format key: uuid:849b9731-485c-33bf-815b-c8bc20081518
11.3.1.3
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:protocol:serverAuthenticatedSSL3
Derived V1,V2 format key: uuid:ef6ae0d7-3495-3abc-b420-49938b569f97
should be
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:protocol:serverauthenticatedssl3
Derived V1,V2 format key: uuid:f69b10e9-b469-3c6c-bbac-3b6cab6cb2d8
11.3.2.3
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:protocol:mutualAuthenticatedSSL3
Derived V1,V2 format key: uuid:1c3152fd-04df-301b-a919-2b28cb80a536
should be
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:protocol:mutualauthenticatedssl3
Derived V1,V2 format key: uuid:98a5bf68-d800-3277-b960-842c0db9c049
11.4.1.3
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:findQualifier:approximateMatch
Derived V1,V2 format key: uuid:ebddfefd-71e5-3f74-ac95-9671d4aecaba
should
be
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:findqualifier:approximatematch
Derived V1,V2 format key: uuid:358ca7e0-1623-353b-ad0c-19a6e89467fb
11.4.2.3
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:findQualifier:exactMatch
Derived V1,V2 format key: uuid:3964444e-be78-36b0-836d-12799afef14e
should
be
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:findqualifier:exactmatch
Derived V1,V2 format key: uuid:ce627104-134c-3621-811f-5e343fe69286
11.4.3.3
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:findQualifier:caseInsensitiveMatch
Derived V1,V2 format key: uuid:51a80341-a1cd-3742-8bcd-d6995e6948aa
should
be
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:findqualifier:caseinsensitivematch
Derived V1,V2 format key: uuid:16920aef-cc5a-3d07-9883-28c6bcafa0c9
11.4.4.3
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:findQualifier:caseSensitiveMatch
Derived V1,V2 format key: uuid:48ea42d0-89a5-38ab-950b-5eb37905e1f1
should
be
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:findqualifier:casesensitivematch
Derived V1,V2 format key: uuid:c24d82ed-0eff-3c44-b09e-5bcd95e7adfc
11.4.5.3
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:findQualifier:diacriticsInsensitiveMatch
Derived V1,V2 format key: uuid:9898243a-4a9c-3db0-9df1-9d216ea5fe32
should
be
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:findqualifier:diacriticsinsensitivematch
Derived V1,V2 format key: uuid:cd21a3d8-3706-32f2-92d1-4c1c8ee8f1e9
11.4.6.3
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:findQualifier:diacriticsSensitiveMatch
Derived V1,V2 format key: uuid:83fd3f56-9b34-31cf-8e36-af0d66425808
should
be
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:findqualifier:diacriticssensitivematch
Derived V1,V2 format key: uuid:29180bba-acbb-3f38-a3ac-7a874af06ccf
11.4.7.3
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:sortOrder:binarySort
Derived V1,V2 format key: uuid:3b16998b-86af-38c3-974d-e91c02d5a7d0
should
be
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:sortorder:binarysort
Derived V1,V2 format key: uuid:018f138d-b021-38bc-a675-bc99fa504020
11.4.8.3
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:sortOrder:UTS-10
Derived V1,V2 format key: uuid:06472c03-7453-3cb1-803c-4df859c1429d
should
be
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:sortorder:uts-10
Derived V1,V2 format key: uuid:58f6d414-fc81-3ff5-9c8a-a92948019bec
11.4.9.3
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:findQualifier:caseInsensitiveSort
Derived V1,V2 format key:uuid:aa441fda-ce7d-31a7-995c-51ee1d359d3d
should
be
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:findqualifier:caseinsensitivesort
Derived V1,V2 format key:uuid:d341265c-210b-3666-8dea-3f9e4ade30f6
11.4.10.3
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:findQualifier:caseSensitiveSort
Derived V1,V2 format key:uuid:d0a6e4dd-64ca-3255-b364-e36d4d31496f
should
be
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:findqualifier:casesensitivesort
Derived V1,V2 format key:uuid:c0be9be4-9b98-3068-bb31-4d752c77fa7d
11.4.11.3
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:findQualifier:sortByNameAsc
Derived V1,V2 format key: uuid:7693631b-9556-37b4-949d-d85092bfd29b
should
be
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:findqualifier:sortbynameasc
Derived V1,V2 format key: uuid:67763c24-13e4-36a6-8f9c-759a720125f5
11.4.12.3
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:findQualifier:sortByNameDesc
Derived V1,V2 format key: uuid:2f19aa82-cb0f-3d1f-83f7-d398555bc290
should
be
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:findqualifier:sortbynamedesc
Derived V1,V2 format key: uuid:71a0573a-94d0-34d9-8729-13667e3691eb
11.4.13.3
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:findQualifier:sortByDateAsc
Derived V1,V2 format key: uuid:90a05e5b-2fbb-30a4-b672-5c8d12bd6dea
should
be
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:findqualifier:sortbydateasc
Derived V1,V2 format key: uuid:b6d62fde-2636-3136-8f51-0ebc4d519821
11.4.14.3
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:findQualifier:sortByDateDesc
Derived V1,V2 format key: uuid:ae947d4f-d689-3c3f-97d6-e77d1998b2f2
should
be
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:findqualifier:sortbydatedesc
Derived V1,V2 format key: uuid:415c8b8a-4577-3b70-bda5-95f7d74940b7
11.4.15.3
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:findQualifier:andAllKeys
Derived V1,V2 format key: uuid:34210649-a605-3143-a33e-07295146575a
should
be
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:findqualifier:andallkeys
Derived V1,V2 format key: uuid:a9863bc6-acb1-307d-9ba2-9358fa3ad53
11.4.16.3
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:findQualifier:orAllKeys
Derived V1,V2 format key: uuid:ea6e816e-8918-3b8d-8441-f2210dd4c4ec
should
be
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:findqualifier:orallkeys
Derived V1,V2 format key: uuid:c6e32585-de42-3ecf-85f5-b4ba541ec396
11.4.17.3
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:findQualifier:orLikeKeys
Derived V1,V2 format key: uuid:fa2b751e-a8d6-35d8-a2ea-2a12d5b178e9
should
be
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:findqualifier:orlikekeys
Derived V1,V2 format key: uuid:804ba4b1-ac56-314b-bea7-a42a93fc8272
11.4.18.3
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:findQualifier:combineCategoryBags
Derived V1,V2 format key: uuid:693a8207-3607-3ced-a923-5bc60f21de23
should
be
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:findqualifier:combinecategorybags
Derived V1,V2 format key: uuid:ca7abfb8-a766-3a68-9e3f-fd792d2b3d11
11.4.19.3
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:findQualifier:serviceSubset
V1,V2 format key:
uuid:9dc599f1-1ee2-3736-b4be-da919e6b1063
should
be
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:findqualifier:servicesubset
Derived V1,V2 format key:
uuid:aedb3e15-dd4c-3869-af9f-9cdf1b936a08
11.4.20.3
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:findQualifier:bindingSubset
Derived V1,V2 format key: uuid:8bdfa975-19ac-38a2-bdd3-715878beb9ef
should
be
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:findqualifier:bindingsubset
Derived V1,V2 format key: uuid:467da549-19ca-3401-8568-2154094f1cfb
11.4.21.3
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:findQualifier:suppressProjectedServices
Derived V1,V2 format key: uuid:0943f989-37f0-3c02-a0ae-6a9627f2bc95
should
be
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:findqualifier:suppressprojectedservices
Derived V1,V2 format key: uuid:59251dbf-90c6-347c-bfad-8b0cf3c2b81a
11.4.22.3
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:findQualifier:signaturePresent
Derived V1,V2 format key: uuid:2b661025-b4a4-3a3f-b60e-e7d68c21ec85
should
be
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:findqualifier:signaturepresent
Derived V1,V2 format key: uuid:8f6749e1-8d9b-30fd-8a21-7597ec993935
11.5.1.3
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:keyGenerator
Derived V1, V2 format key: uuid:536470bb-3294-3d30-91e4-df0fcbd1a5d9
should
be
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:keygenerator
Derived V1, V2 format key: uuid:06aad04f-ec26-3038-be78-897eed195689
also, signature needs to be recalculated
11.5.2.3
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:specification:hostingRedirector
Derived V1,V2 format key: uuid:966a3c13-7d00-4586-9def-b270b1b32c7d
should
be
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:specification:hostingredirector
Derived V1,V2 format key: uuid:c284e6eb-3633-3f56-ab9c-90d37a213f21
Andrew Hately
IBM Austin
UDDI Development, Emerging Technologies
Lotus Notes: Andrew Hately/Austin/IBM@IBMUS
Internet: hately@us.ibm.com
(512) 838-2866, t/l 678-2866
| Andrew Hately/Austin/IBM@IBMUS
05/05/2003 02:50 PM
|
|
To
| "Luc Clement" <lclement@windows.microsoft.com>
|
|
cc
| "CAHUZAC Maud / FTR&D
/ US" <maud.cahuzac@rd.francetelecom.com>, uddi-spec@lists.oasis-open.org
|
|
Subject
| RE: [uddi-spec] IsReplacedBy
TModel comments |
|
Luc,
As a related item, I have a list of updated keys for those V2 keys produced
by hashing... something I missed in the update for case-folding, as case
folding must happen before the hashing.
I will check the list later tonight and make sure I hashed all the values
correctly and then post the result.
Andrew Hately
IBM Austin
UDDI Development, Emerging Technologies
Lotus Notes: Andrew Hately/Austin/IBM@IBMUS
Internet: hately@us.ibm.com
(512) 838-2866, t/l 678-2866
| "Luc Clement"
<lclement@windows.microsoft.com>
05/04/2003 11:14 PM
|
|
To
| "CAHUZAC Maud
/ FTR&D / US" <maud.cahuzac@rd.francetelecom.com>, <uddi-spec@lists.oasis-open.org>
|
|
cc
|
|
|
Subject
| RE: [uddi-spec] IsReplacedBy
TModel comments |
|
Maud,
I was going through mail to look for items not covered and found that your's
hadn't been dealt with.
Each of the v2 and v3 specs are OK wrt the keys they use. I'll point out
that the key used in the v3 spec is a v3 derived key (i.e. uuid:54AF30AE-9B61-385C-9D1D-AB572E72BFF2).
The original tModel's v2 key is: uuid:E59AE320-77A5-11D5-B898-0004AC49CC1E.
TC:
That said, while reviewing your note, I think I've identified an error
with the tModel's name whereby it should be have been named "uddi-org:isReplacedBy_v3"
rather than "uddi-org:isReplacedBy" given that this tModel is
a replacement, and that for purpose of consistency with other similarly
replaced tModels, it should have been renamed. If folks agree, I'd propose
that this be added to CR-002.
11.1.6.2
tModel
Definition
Name:
uddi-org:isReplacedBy
<<< in error ???
Description:
An identifier system used to point to the entity,
using UDDI keys, that is the logical replacement for the one in which isReplacedBy
is used.
UDDI Key (V3):
uddi:uddi.org:identifier:isReplacedBy
Derived V1, V2 format key: uuid:54AF30AE-9B61-385C-9D1D-AB572E72BFF2
Categorization:
identifier
Checked:
Yes
From: CAHUZAC Maud / FTR&D /
US [mailto:maud.cahuzac@rd.francetelecom.com]
Sent: Thursday, April 03, 2003 17:22
To: 'uddi-spec@lists.oasis-open.org'
Subject: [uddi-spec] IsReplacedBy TModel comments
Hi everybody,
I have 2 little comments regarding the CR "isReplacedBy tModel"
(uddi-spec-tc-cr010-isreplacedby-20030304.doc):
First, in the UDDI V2.0 part, section 5.4.2 10.4 Example of Use, I don't
understand the value of the tModelKey in the keyedReference.
I thought this value was the TModelkey of the "IsReplacedBy"
TModel :
<tModel tModelKey=uuid:64C756D1-3374-4E00-AE83-EE12E38FAE63>
...
<name>uddi-org:publication</name>
...
<categoryBag>
<!-- Use uddi-org:IsReplacedBy to indicate that this tModel
(the uddi V1 publication tModel) is
logically replaced by the V2 publication tModel.
-->
<keyedReference keyName="uddi-org:publication_v2"
keyValue="uuid:A2F33B65-2D66-4088-ABC7-914D0E05EB9E"
tModelKey="uuid:54AF30AE-9B61-385C-9D1D-AB572E72BFF2"/>
(instead of "uuid:E59AE320-77A5-11D5-B898-0004AC49CC1E")
</categoryBag>
...
</tModel>
Also, in the UDDI V3.0 part, section 5.5.1.4 11.1.6.4 Example of Use, the
value of the tModelKey in the keyedReference
should be "uddi.org:categorization:isReplacedBy" instead of "uddi:uddi.org:identifier:isReplacedBy"
(am I wrong?)
Thanks,
Maud
Maud Cahuzac,
Technical Analyst
france telecom
R&D, LLC
801 Gateway Boulevard, Suite 500
South San Francisco, CA 94080
Phone:(650) 875-1577
Fax :(650) 875-1505
Email: maud.cahuzac@rd.francetelecom.com
[Date Prev]
| [Thread Prev]
| [Thread Next]
| [Date Next]
--
[Date Index]
| [Thread Index]
| [List Home]