Re: [ws-rx] Proposal for i004

[Anish Karmarkar <Anish.Karmarkar@oracle.com>]

Marc Goodner wrote:
> I’ve looked into this issue and I believe it is not an issue and should 
> be closed as follows.
> 
>  
> 
> Proposal:
> 
> Web Services Addressing says that the wsa:messageID may be the same for 
> a retransmitted message. Therefore when a message is retransmitted with 
> the same wsrm:{Identifier, MessageNumber} pair the wsa:messageID may be 
> the same. The correct use of wsa:messageID need not be redocumented in 
> this specification therefore this issue should be closed with no action.
> 

Shouldn't it say 'MUST' rather than a 'may'? Why would the wsa:MessageID 
(or more appropriately [message id]) be different for a retransmission 
in the context of WSRM? Or for that matter anything else in the Infoset 
that is transmitted.

Also, can you point me to the text in WSA where it says this?

Thx!

-Anish
--