NEW Issue - WS-BA: State Table Errata

[Thomas Freund <tjfreund@us.ibm.com>]

Protocol:  WS-BA
 
Artifact:  spec
 
Draft:  BA specification CD 02
 
Link to the document referenced:
 
http://www.oasis-open.org/committees/download.php/18818/wstx-wsba-1.1-spec-cd-02.pdf

 

Section and PDF line number: see proposed resolution listed below

Issue type: design

 

Related issues:
 
Issue Description: WS-BA State Table Errata

Proposed Resolution:

C1. PC/PV Inbound

• Title "BusinessAgreementWithParticantCompletion" should read "BusinessAgreementWithParticipantCompletion"
• Correct "States" Column heading: Failing (Active, Canceling, Completed) should read Failing (Active, Canceling)
• Failing cells should indicate fully-qualified failure failing-active, failing-canceling or failing-compensating (rather than failing)

C1. PC/PV Outbound

• Title "BusinessAgreementWithParticantCompletion" should read "BusinessAgreementWithParticipantCompletion
• Failing cells should include a note to indicate fully-qualified failures include failing-active, failing-canceling or failing-compensating (rather than failing)

C2. PC/CV Inbound

• Title "BusinessAgreementWithParticantCompletion" should read "BusinessAgreementWithParticipantCompletion"
• Failing cells should indicate fully-qualified failure failing-active, failing-canceling or failing-compensating (rather than failing)

C2. PC/CV Outbound

• Title "BusinessAgreementWithParticantCompletion" should read "BusinessAgreementWithParticipantCompletion"
• Failing cells should include a note to indicate fully-qualified failures include failing-active, failing-canceling or failing-compensating (rather than failing)

C3. CC/PV Inbound

• Correct "States" Column heading: Failing (Active, Canceling, Completed) should read Failing (Active, Canceling, Completing)
• Failing cells should indicate fully-qualified failure failing-active, failing-canceling, failing-completing or failing-compensating (rather than failing)

C3. CC/PV Outbound

• Failing cells should include a note to indicate fully-qualified failures include failing-active, failing-canceling. failing-completing or failing-compensating (rather than failing)

C4. CC/CV Inbound

• Failing cells should indicate fully-qualified failure failing-active, failing-canceling, failing completing or failing-compensating (rather than failing)
• Appropriate Canceling(Active) cells should indicate fully-qualified failure canceling-active (rather than canceling for inbound events completed, closed & compensated)
• Appropriate Canceling(Completing) cells should indicate fully-qualified failure canceling-completing (rather than canceling for inbound events closed & compensated)
• Failing/Completing cell should be failing-completing rather than failing-active

C4. CC/CV Outbound

• Canceling cells should include a note to indicate fully-qualified failures include canceling-active or canceling-completing (rather than canceling)
• Failing cells should include a note to indicate fully-qualified failures include failing-active, failing-canceling. failing-completing or failing-compensating (rather than failing)

NB: Given these clarifications a (non-qualified) failing is never used in the state tables and should be removed from the GetStatus enumeration (wsba.xsd)

A non-qualified canceling is only used by the participant