Fw: issues coordination call jan 12 notes

[Diane Jordan <drj@us.ibm.com>]

Notes from our call today.  Yaron,
Monica and I participated.  
- suggestion that we should not try
to address 107 until 82 is completely closed.  I'd like Peter's view
on this as the proposer.  
To close 82, we need: 
- the list of questions/items that need
to be added to complete the proposal.  I will send an email reminding
the TC that we're expecting their questions identifying gaps in the proposal
by the Jan 19 meeting.  These questions should address areas that
are not covered, rather than reopening discussion on the content of hte
82 proposal that was approved.   
-once we have the list of questions
(which may be void if no one provides any in a reasonable time) we will
work to have them addressed.   
- next phase of work to complete resolution
of 82 will be to request a more detailed write up of the changes to the
spec.   
Yaron reports that a proposal for issue
103 has been completed and is under review.  Its most likely going
to take a couple weeks to get it to the full list. 
He also indicated 125 is related to
157 as well as 51.  He expects 51 and 157 may take a lot of work and
is unsure when we will get to it.  
 
Regards, Diane
IBM  Emerging Internet Software Standards
drj@us.ibm.com
(919)254-7221 or 8-444-7221, Mobile: 919-624-5123, Fax 845-491-5709

----- Forwarded by Diane
Jordan/Raleigh/IBM on 01/12/2005 04:40 PM -----

Diane Jordan/Raleigh/IBM

01/12/2005 12:53 PM

To	bpel rqmts
cc
Subject	issues coordination call today 1pm pacific/4pm eastern

Hi,
Sorry for the late reminder - we'll
have our bi-weekly issues call today. Call
in info is: 877-988-8393, int'l 203 566-8013, pc 770954. 
Topic is agenda for next meeting.  Here's
where I think we stand right now:  
New issues to be opened:  182,
183
Issues with new proposals this week:
->none so far
Issues deferred from previous meetings:
-> issues 125: pending resolution
of 103 and 51
-> 169: pending availability of Satish
and Yuzo
-> 160: Alex had sent a draft proposal
for this - I'm checking with him if he wants to go to a vote.  
-> issue 11.1 - deferred to provide
more time for review 
-> issue 81 ??? I see this has had
a proposal since Dec but somehow can't recall previous discussions 
-> issue 92: pending updated proposal
from Dieter
Long running issues
-> issue 103: work in progress
-> issue 2: work in progress 
-> issue 82: review any questions
on additional material to be added  
-> issues  107: I've asked Peter
if he'll be ready to discuss his proposal at the next call
->issues  91, 97 99:  pending
closure of 107  
-> issue 126:  deferred pending
107 
-> issue 9: deferred pending inclusion of 84 in spec
-> issue 125: pending 103 and 51


Peter,  
I think there's some housekeeping to do on
the list.   
The status of 12 is messed up.  We had
a proposal from Yaron.  During the f2f, he changed it to be a proposal
for a new issue "12.1" which was voted on and closed.  
Yaron split out issue 12.2 as well and opened a new issue on rethrows (183).
 
12 is showing up on the list as having a
proposal to vote and 12.2 is showing up as a new issue to be accepted -
I don't think we'd intended subissues to go through the "bug"
vote since they're parts of issues already open.  Would you please
just move 12.2 to open, open and close 12.1 with the original issue 12
proposal and take 12 off the list of issues with proposals to vote?  The
minutes from the f2f are now available on the web site, which may help.
 
Yaron - we may need a short description for
12.1.

Also,  issue 11 is showing up on the
list as having a proposal - I think it because 11.1 has a proposal and
so don't think it should be there - am I right?  Thanks.  

Regards, Diane
IBM  Emerging Internet Software Standards
drj@us.ibm.com
(919)254-7221 or 8-444-7221, Mobile: 919-624-5123, Fax 845-491-5709