From:	David RR Webber - XML ebusiness [Gnosis_@compuserve.com]
Sent:	Monday, August 18, 2003 2:08 PM
To:	Sally St. Amand
Subject:	RE: Use case template
Sally,

More comments - this is where the thread sits on
the CEFACT side right now.

You can subscribe to the list if you want to
its free and open.

DW

-------------Forwarded Message-----------------

From:	"UN/CEFACT TMG UBAC Project Team", INTERNET:uncefact-tmg-ubac@listman.disa.org
To:	"UN/CEFACT TMG UBAC Project Team", INTERNET:uncefact-tmg-ubac@listman.disa.org
	
Date:	8/11/2003  8:45 AM

RE:	RE: Use case template

Dear Anders,

Hereafter are some suggestions :
- Stakeholders are business/problem domain entities while Actors are closer
to the solution domain (they interact with the system use cases). These two
types of elements needs to be identified. I am not sure that separation is
required. I think it will be appropriate to mention the stakeholder name in
the actor's description . 
- Primary actor should be first in the Actors field.

Best regards
Noel

-----Original Message-----
From: Anders W. Tell [mailto:anderst@toolsmiths.se]
Sent: lundi 11 août 2003 13:40
To: UN/CEFACT TMG UBAC Project Team
Subject: Re: Use case template

Thanks Noel,

The comments are good and relevant, Ill forward the comments to the 
contributing company. They are completing the use case so we can bring 
it up here and discuss it.

Do you think there is a need to add template field(s) in order to 
separate actors and stakeholders or is it sufficient to mark them in the 
participant field?

best regards
/anders

Noel Yavo wrote:

> Anders,
>
> Hereafter are some comments on the proposed Use case for UBAC. 
>
> Actors (interacting with the use case ) should clearly differentiated 
> from Stakeholders.
> Pre-condions should clearly state the state which are the condition 
> that must be fullfilled for the submitted contract form be accepted by 
> the recipient (authenticated sender, appropriately identified 
> recipient with a GLN - global location number for example, all 
> mandatory information provided,at least on exchange item on the 
> form,..). The post-condition should also identify the output (contract).
>
> The provided goal  looks more like a list of benefits. The goal should 
> identify the use case actor, the activity and the outcome (ex. Carrier 
> delivers goods)
>
> Best regards,
> Noel YAVO
> Modeller @ EAN International
>
> -----Original Message-----
> From: Anders W. Tell [mailto:anderst@toolsmiths.se]
> Sent: jeudi 7 août 2003 19:30
> To: UN/CEFACT TMG UBAC Project Team
> Subject: Use case template
>
>
> Dear all,
>
> I have assembled a use case template for UBAC requirements capturing
> that I would like get your opinion on.  Please have a look at the
> template, which is based on forthcomming UMM user guide forms, and get
> back with feedback to the list or one the editors.
>
> Attached is also a sample use case: Contract forms
>
> best regards
> /Anders W. Tell
>
> -- 
> /////////////////////////////////////
> / Business Collaboration Toolsmiths /
> / website: <www.toolsmiths.se>      /
> / email: <anderst@toolsmiths.se>    /
> / phone: +46 8 545 885 87           /
> / mobile: +46 70 546 66 03          /
> /////////////////////////////////////
>