TC call Minutes 5/11/06

[Heather Kreger <kreger@us.ibm.com>]

Hi All,

TC call mintues:=20
Discussed public comments and process  today:=20

Reviewd comments from CA attatched to bottom.=20

Proposed editorial changes to WSDM MUWS Part 1.=20

Line  127 - Remove car engine

Line 128 - change WSRF to WS

Line 143 - The definition of Manageability Capacity Interface should be=20
eliminated (it is not longer used in the specificaiton).  The definition=20
of Manageability Interface should be changed to "A Web service interface=20
that exposes interfaces for one or more manageability capabilities."

Exit Public Comment on 5/19.=20
Heather needs to=20
1. see how to treat 'non substantive changes' in the process.  If
this=20
causes re-review of the spec then we may choose not to do this.=20
2. see how long a CD special ballot takes - ballot or  phone?=20
3. run simultaneous with approval to submit - ballot or phone?=20

Heather Kreger
STSM, Web Services Lead Architect for SWG Emerging Technologies
Author of "Java and JMX: Building Manageable Systems"
kreger@us.ibm.com
919-543-3211 (t/l 441)  cell:919-496-9572

----- Forwarded by Heather Kreger/Raleigh/IBM on 05/11/2006 12:35 PM -----

comment-form@oasis-open.org=20
04/14/2006 09:33 AM
Please respond to
kirk.wilson@ca.com


To
wsdm-comment@lists.oasis-open.org
cc

Subject
[wsdm-comment] Public Comment






Comment from: kirk.wilson@ca.com

Name: Kirk Wilson
Title:  Architect, office of CTO
Organization: CA, Inc.
Regarding Specification:  WSDM MUWS 1.1

Comments regarding definitions in section 1.1 of MUWS Part 1.

1.  Line 127: a "car engine" is not an intutively obvious
example of an IT =

resource.

2.  The definition of "WSRF Resource" is actually the definition
of a=20
WS-Resource in the WS-Resource specification.  It is not clear why
another =

term needs to be introduced in this spec for this technical concept.  This
=

can only lead to confusion.  I suspect that what is intended by "WSRF=20
Resource" in WSDM is what the WS-R specification defines as a "resource",=20
namely:
A resource is a logical entity that has the following characteristics:
? It MUST be identifiable.
? It MUST have a set of zero or more properties, which are expressible
in=20
XML infoset.
? It MAY have lifecycle.
MUWS should (1) introduce the preceding definition as the definition of=20
"WSRF Resource" and (2) change the term "WSRF Resource"
to "WS-Resource"=20
in line 128.  (Also, the definition should be made more explicit by=20
referring to "WSRF Resource" rather than simply "resource".

3.  The definition of Manageability Capacity Interface should be=20
eliminated (it is not longer used in the specificaiton).  The definition=20
of Manageability Interface should be changed to "A Web service interface=20
that exposes one or more manageability capabilities."