WSN action items

["Vambenepe, William N" <vbp@hp.com>]

Hi all,

I went through all the minutes and extracted the action items as of the
end of the F2F. Thanks to the minute takers for the excellent job with
extra credit to Bryan for putting a summary of the action items at the
beginning.

Notes:

- I removed the action items that were just asking spec editors to act
on issues with "approach agreed" (this is an implicit action item
whenever there is an "approach agreed")

- I went through Sanjay's latest post of the issues list
(http://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/wsn/download.php/11361/WSN
_IssuesList1.9.doc) and marked as DONE below those that I saw done to
speed things up during conf call

Regards,

William




Action items:

AI 7 - WS-BrokeredNotif editors to adopt for WSN2.15 the same resolution
as WSRF did for their issue 30: WSA:action must match the SOAP uri

AI 10 . Use case: Managing message rates? Igor 

AI 11 . Use case: Boxcarring? Martin & Anish 

AI 14 - RickC/Lily to write a proposal for WSN2.28 (from Oct F2F)

AI 16 - Peter and Igor to write proposal to add XPath 1 and XPath 2 as
dialect (1st option in the list of options for issue WSN4.3 (from Oct
F2F) 

AI 18 - Sanjay to create new issue based on Peter and Steve's
clarification of wsrp:Dialect use. i.e. why this element is valuable and
how is it applicable to the WSN uses. (from [1])

AI 19 - Sanjay to add an issue on "Ordering & interleaving of
notifications" (suggestion to add some text to BaseN to make it explicit
that this topic is not addressed in BaseN and push these kind of
semantics into the policy document) (from [1]) DONE

AI 20 - Sanjay to add an issue on "Defining the concept of "sending" a
notification" (and tie into it reliability of brokers) (from [1])

AI 21 - David Hull to look at text dealing with delivering notifications
and suggest clarifications (from [1])

AI 22 - William to explore the possibility of saying something on using
the wsa:RelatesTo header in the context of WS-Notification (from [1])

AI 23 - WS-BaseN editors to correct inconsistency between wsnt:Topic in
xsd and wsnt:Topics in text by moving both to TopicExpression (from [1])

AI 24 - WS-BaseN editors to make proposal in spec for tightening
description of faults (from [1]).

AI 25 - WS-BrokeredN editors to make proposal in spec for tightening
description of faults (from [1]).

AI 26 - Rick to go through WS-BaseN and WS-BrokeredN and identify
baseline policy behaviors (i.e. default behaviors when no explicit
policies) (from [1]).

AI 27 - Dave Snelling to review existing documents for baseline policy.
(from [1]).

AI 28 - WS-BaseN editors to consolidate all schema in xsd files, i.e.
move xsd out of wsdl into separate file.  (from [1]).

AI 29 - WS-BrokeredN editors to consolidate all schema in xsd files,
i.e. move xsd out of wsdl into separate file.  (from [1]).

AI 30 - Sanjay to close 4.12 with no action (from [1]) DONE

AI 31 - Sanjay to close 4.13 with no action (from [1]) DONE

AI 32 - Sanjay to close 4.14 with no action (from [1]) DONE

AI 33 - Sanjay to close 4.1 and open three new "approach agreed" issues
with following decisions (from [1]): DONE
  - WS-BaseN editors to define a location attribute for topicspace doc
  - WS-BaseN editors to allow attribute extensibility on TopicExpression
resource prop
  - primer editors to explain this and give advice on using the location
attribute

AI 34 - Sanjay to mark 4.4 as approach agreed with resolution from [2]
DONE

AI 35 - Sanjay: NEW ISSUE - Add 'final' attribute to the TopicSpace, and
describe what is the default if the attribute is not specified. (from
[3]) DONE

AI 36 - Sanjay: NEW ISSUE - Tighten WS-BaseN TopicExpression text such
that if a wild card expression is used it must not generate a
TopicUnknown fault and to rename the Topic property to TopicExpression -
reference issue 4.15 (from [3])

AI 37 - Sanjay: Close issue 4.15. The text from 4.15 moves into new
issue for best practices.  (from [3]) DONE

AI 38 - Sanjay: NEW ISSUE - Best practices with text from 4.15  (from
[3]) DONE

AI 39 - Sanjay: Close 4.7 and say it is addressed by the new issue for
best practices opened above (from [3]) DONE

AI 40 - Sanjay: Move 4.16 to agreed approach, add text saying the
behavior is as if the expression is evaluated every time an event is
generated. Add this to WS-Topics. (from [3]) DONE.

AI 41 - Sanjay: Close 4.19 with no change (from [3]) DONE
 
AI 42 - WS-Topics editors: remove wording about dialects being
XPath-like (4.3)

AI 43 - Sanjay: close issue 4.10 with no action (from [3]) DONE

AI 44 - WS-Topics editors and Glen: replace section 10 with a single
sentence saying it is possible to define a topic space with a namespace
of ''. Glen to propose wording for this sentence. (4.9)

AI 45 - Sanjay: closed 4.11 no change (from [3]) DONE

AI 46 - Sanjay: change 4.20 to approach agreed (resolution already in
the issues list) (from [3]) DONE

AI 47 - Fred: Explain what issue 4.18 means

AI 48 - Sanjay: Record on issue 3.4 that we want to investigate policy
based solution for this issue. (from [3]) DONE

AI 49 - Sanjay to mark 2.1 as "approach agreed" with agreement from F2F.
(from [3]) DONE


References:

[1]
http://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/wsn/download.php/11381/wsn-
minutes-1-31-2005.txt

[2]
http://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/wsn/download.php/11377/wsnf
2fFeb01AM.txt

[3]
http://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/wsn/download.php/11333/WSNf
2fFeb01PM.doc

[4]
http://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/wsn/download.php/11309/2005
0202-wsn-minutes.html