Re: [wsrm] Contribution suggestions just uploaded

["Iwasa" <kiwasa@jp.fujitsu.com>]

All,

Since we are almost there, I would like to
pursue possibility to meet 8/15 deadline
for voting of the spec itself and its submission
to OASIS. Would it be possible to realize that if:
    - We agree the resolution for all remaining issues
      at the telecon.(if any)
    - Editors publish the final version of the spec
      by the end of Thursday 8/12.
    - Additional telecon on Friday afternoon/evening 8/13.
       (This must have quorum.)
       The possible agenda is:
            - Check the last updates one by one.
            - Voting for the spec to be CD
            - Voting for OASIS submission
 ?

Any thoughts?

Thanks,

Iwasa

----- Original Message ----- 
From: "Doug Bunting" <Doug.Bunting@Sun.COM>
To: "wsrm" <wsrm@lists.oasis-open.org>
Sent: Sunday, August 08, 2004 8:14 AM
Subject: [wsrm] Contribution suggestions just uploaded


> The contribution I just uploaded[1,2,3] represents another improvement on
> (but not the culmination of everything required to fix) the issues
> discussed in my long-ago "Summary of WS-Reliability 1.01* issues discussed
> over past week" email as well as the more recent "Detailed review of
> Section 2-2.5, 5.2 and related definitions" and "about review of Section
> 2-2.5, 5.2".  We have made a lot of progress on improvements in this area
> but a bit more remains.
>
> Note that the two footnotes I inserted are not intended for the final
> document but simply explain a few deletions.  Those deletions also make
the
> footnotes much less sensible when not viewing the differences.
>
> Primary areas of concern addressed in this contribution include:
> - The BP 1.0 WSDL / SOAP / HTTP restrictions inappropriately were applied
> to the allowed abstract operations used at the producer / consumer level.
> It does not make sense to apply HTTP and SOAP restrictions to the way in
> which a SOAP processor (our RMP component) is invoked.  That represents an
> unnecessary restriction reaching across 3 abstraction layers.
>
> - A few remaining clarity issues.  For example, while WSDL might be
written
> down to describe the RMP use of the underlying protocol, we have not done
> so.  In spite of this lack, "WSDL" is occasionally used in ways that are
> ambiguous.
>
> - A lack of support for the BP 1.0 restrictions presented in Section 6.
We
> need to generically describe various message exchanges as following the
> patterns introduced in Section 2.3 ("SOAP one-way MEP" and "SOAP
> request-response MEP") before the HTTP binding builds on those
assumptions.
>   A few more assumptions and implications needed to be written down.  This
> was particularly troubling in light of the over-generality previously in
> 2.5.2 and 2.5.3.
>
> - Application of a SOAP One-way MEP restriction in 6.3 to the synchronous
> Poll RM-Reply Pattern case.  Fixed by moving the appropriate restrictions
> into 6.3.1 and 6.3.2.
>
> The specification still does a poor job describing when the Respond
> operation is or is not supported.  Nor does it make clear the "meaning" of
> a payload in a message containing only a Response header or that messages
> with none of the Request, Response or PollRequest headers have no
> significance under the WS-Reliability protocol.  Both classes of change
> would likely be more significant than I undertook.  For example, it might
> be reasonable to link the first Reliable Message "mentioned" in a Response
> element with a payload in the same message but that would extend the rules
> in 4.4 beyond the Response RM-Reply Pattern.  This contribution attempts
to
> illustrate the differences between the Producer / Consumer interface and
> the SOAP message exchanges the RMPs implement but may not be "complete" in
> this respect either.
>
> thanx,
> doug
>
> [1]
>
http://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/wsrm/download.php/8586/WS-Reliability-2004-08-07-drb.sxw
> [2]
>
http://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/wsrm/download.php/8587/WS-Reliability-2004-08-07-drb.pdf
> [3]
>
http://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/wsrm/download.php/8588/WS-Reliability-2004-08-07-drb-diff.pdf
>
> To unsubscribe from this mailing list (and be removed from the roster of
the OASIS TC), go to
http://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/wsrm/members/leave_workgroup.php.
>