Re: [wsrp-interfaces] Custom user profile items

[Subbu Allamaraju <subbu@bea.com>]

My problem statement is that "the v1 spec left where to carry user 
profile items." Since there is nothing specified, there is no issue of 
ambiguity.

Subbu

Rich Thompson wrote:
> 
> In reflecting on this mornings call, I think Mike is right in that we 
> have not well enough defined the problem we are working on and this is 
> complicating discussing solutions. My summary of the problem statements 
> I have heard is:
>  
>  Richard: The v1 metadata for custom user profiles items is insufficient 
> to locate and understand the items (i.e. reasonably support mapping).
>  Subbu: The v1 spec left where custom user profile items are placed 
> ambiguous.
>  Andre: The protocol should cleanly support user profile schemas defined 
> outside the TC.
> 
> I think Subbu's problem statement is a narrowing of Richard's with a 
> strong indication of a preferred solution. I think Andre's statement is 
> the broadest of the three proposed problem statements. If we can settle 
> on which one(s) of these, if any, we are willing to accept as problems, 
> it should help scope the discussion/solution in a productive manner.
> 
> Rich