[Date Prev] | [Thread Prev] | [Thread Next] | [Date Next] -- [Date Index] | [Thread Index] | [Elist Home]
Subject: [wsrp-wsia] Minutes for 20 February 2003 Meeting
Minutes for WSRP teleconference on 2/20/03
-----------------------------------------------------------
Meeting begain at 9:09 PST
============================================================
Roll Call
Voting Members in Attendance:
Abdelnur, Alejandro Sun Microsystems yes
Aickin, Sasha Plumtree Software yes
Allamaruaju, Subbu BEA Systems Inc. yes
Atkinson, Olin Novell yes
Blich, Amir SAP yes
Braun, Chris Novell no
Brooks, Rex Starbourne yes
Cox, T.J. Novell no
Cox, William BEA Systems Inc. no
Dirking, Brian Stellent no
Freedman, Michael Oracle Corporation yes
Fubini, Ross Plumtree Software yes
Jacob, Richard IBM yes
Klein, Jon Reed-Elsevier yes
Kramer, Andre Citrix Systems, Inc. yes
Kropp, Alan Vignette Corporation yes
Leue, Carsten IBM yes
Machak, Dan TIBCO Software Inc. yes
Mitsuoka, Madoka Fujitsu no
Nolan, Adam Reed-Elsevier yes
Rameshl, Raj CommerceOne yes
Randhawa, Sunit Fujitsu no
Ratcliffe, Nigel Factiva no
Schaeck, Thomas IBM yes
Shumakher, Gennady SAP no
Smith, Steven Capitol College no
Tamari, Yossi SAP yes
Tayar, Gil WebCollage yes
Thompson, Rich IBM yes
van Lydegraf, Eric Kinzan no
Young, Michael Plumtree Software no
Wiecha, Charles IBM no
Total voting members: 32
Voting members in attendance: 20 (62%)
A quorum was present.
Prospective Members in Attendance:
Batra, Atul Sun Microsystems yes
Observers in Attendance:
Martin, Monica Drake Certivo no
Members on Leave of Absence
Filicetti, Gino Bowstreet no
Palas, Petr Moravia IT no
Reshef, Eilon WebCollage no
Rudnicki, Joe U.S. Navy no
============================================================
The minutes were accepted from the teleconferance on 2/13/02
============================================================
Rich started addressing the outstanding change requests.
All of the following changes were accepted without
objection:
Small editorial/grammar changes :
145 - Missing 'the' in 6.1.10
146 - Rearrange phrases in 6.2.1.1
148 - Explicitly "session" scope
149 - Respecting grouping
150 - Typing of extensions
152 - Drop "is"
154 - false -> "false"
159 - Delete reference to included field
160 - Update useCachedMarkup description
161 - Ports, not bindings
163 - Plural field names for arrays
============================================================
Summary of the substantive changes:
139 - Add UpdateResponse.isSecure? TABLED
140 - Add PortletDescription.onlySecure? ACCEPTED
141 - Add previous windowState and mode? TABLED
157 - Add pushesPersistentState? NOT ACCEPTED
136 - Producer supported user profile types ACCEPTED
137 - Producer supported window states and modes ACCEPTED
138 - How does info get to proxied resources TABLED
============================================================
139 - Add UpdateResponse.isSecure?
Reasoning: This is the only case where the Producer
cannot control security of the transport.
Tabled for this week. Discussion was taking too long.
============================================================
140 - Add PortletDescription.onlySecure?
Reasoning: JSR-168 Alignment. A JSR-168
portlet can describe itself as always being secure.
The technical reason is that this allows the Consumer
to optimize the user experience.
Resolved: the flag will be added to PortletDescription
============================================================
141 - Add previous windowState and mode?
Reasoning: JSR-168 Alignment. This will allow
the Producer to get back to the mode or window state
it was in prior to being changed by the Consumer.
Tabled for this week. Allow people to think about it
============================================================
157 - Add pushesPersistentState?
Reasoning: Allow Producers to specify that it will
require Consumers to store persisted state.
Mike raised the point that it is not optional for
Consumers to support persistence.
Resolved: Don't do this in version 1. Perhaps in a
future version, we may relax the constraint on
Consumers having to support persistence.
============================================================
136 - Producer supported user profile types
Reasoning: JSR-168 Alignment. Allows having localized
descriptions of the profiles. This will be similar to
userCategoryDesciptions
Resolved: Will define userProfileDescription similar
to userCategoryDescription. Provided in Producer
description.
============================================================
137 - Producer supported window states and modes
Reasoning: JSR-168 Alignment. Same behavior as for
userProfileDescriptions in CR 136.
Resolved: accepted
============================================================
138 - How does info get to proxied resources (Insert a new section
10.4?)
Reasoning: Some proxied resources need to have access
to additional state in order to execute properly.
Question on whether Consumers need to handle cookies
in accordance with the cookie spec.
Resolved: The section will probably be useful, but
there are still some open questions. Continue with
email discussion
============================================================
Next week will do a 1-hour call on Tuesday and
a 2-hour call on Thursday.
Meeting adjourned at 10:10 PST
[Date Prev] | [Thread Prev] | [Thread Next] | [Date Next] -- [Date Index] | [Thread Index] | [Elist Home]
Powered by eList eXpress LLC