wsrp message
[Date Prev]
| [Thread Prev]
| [Thread Next]
| [Date Next]
--
[Date Index]
| [Thread Index]
| [List Home]
Subject: Re: [wsrp] XSD - Spec comparison
- From: Rich Thompson <richt2@us.ibm.com>
- To: wsrp@lists.oasis-open.org
- Date: Thu, 13 Dec 2007 12:59:17 -0500
Good catch. I've updated those as well.
On the items we carry as attributes,
I checked and found these were the only two where we weren't being explicit
and since the default is different for attributes vs elements, I made them
explicit as well.
Any other items that people's reviews
have found before I publish wd28/cd07 and ask the staff to run the cs02
ballot?
Rich
From:
| Nathan Lipke <nlipke@bea.com>
|
To:
| Nathan Lipke <nlipke@bea.com>
|
Cc:
| Rich Thompson/Watson/IBM@IBMUS, wsrp@lists.oasis-open.org
|
Date:
| 12/13/2007 11:29 AM
|
Subject:
| Re: [wsrp] XSD - Spec comparison |
Also the types similar to NamedString in WSRP-Extra should
allow null values: QNamedMultiValue, NamedMultiValue.
Nate
Nathan Lipke wrote:
See inline...
Rich Thompson wrote:
My take on the editorial errors (i.e. inconsistency between spec and schema):
1. We decided the the extension field is where optionality is defined,
the spec needs to require the "any" content in the extension
type.
2. The schema for LocalizedString needs to say the lang is required and
the resourcename is optional
3. All extensions fields were to be arrays ... fix the spec
4. The parts field should be optional (as per the schema) as this allows
specifying support for a privately defined extension
5. NamedString issue was already caught (& fixed)
I'm not seeing the fix at http://docs.oasis-open.org/wsrp/v2/wsrp-2.0-types.xsd
6. Schema needs to reflect the spec
for resourceState & resourceCachability
I think they do use="optional" is optional (default).
Though as long as we're cleaning up being explicate doesn't hurt.
7. The failed structures were intended
to be consistent, update the spec to match the schema
Any objections to these changes?
Rich
Hi,
as discussed on thursday, we did a thorough review again and found the
following shown in the table below.
Should we have a TC call to discuss that?
|------------------------------------+------------------------------------|
|Extension
| <complexType name="Extension">
|
| [O] Object any
| <sequence>
|
|
|
<any namespace="##other" |
|
|processContents="lax"/>
|
|
| </sequence>
|
|
| </complexType>
|
|any payload required otherwise we |
|
|had an empty extension element |
|
|------------------------------------+------------------------------------|
|LocalizedString
| <complexType
|
| [R] string xmlLang
|name="LocalizedString">
|
| [R] string value
| <sequence>
|
| [O] string resourceName |
<element name="value"
|
|
|type="xsd:string"/>
|
|
| </sequence>
|
|
| <attribute
ref="xml:lang" |
|
|use="optional"/>
|
|
| <attribute
name="resourceName" |
|
|type="xsd:string"/>
|
|
| </complexType>
|
|
|
|
|
|xml:lang should
be required, |
|
|resourceName should
have |
|
|use="optional"
|
|------------------------------------+------------------------------------|
|MarkupType
| <complexType name="MarkupType">
|
| [R] string mimeType
| <sequence>
|
| [R] string modes[]
| <element name="mimeType"
|
| [R] string windowStates[] |type="xsd:string"/>
|
| [O] string locales[]
| <element name="modes"
|
| [O] Extension extensions |type="xsd:string"
|
|
|maxOccurs="unbounded"/>
|
|Should be [O] Extension extensions[]| <element
name="windowStates" |
|instead
|type="xsd:string"
|
|
|maxOccurs="unbounded"/>
|
|
|
<element name="locales" |
|
|type="xsd:string"
minOccurs="0"|
|
|maxOccurs="unbounded"/>
|
|
|
<element name="extensions" |
|
|type="types:Extension"
minOccurs="0"|
|
|maxOccurs="unbounded"/>
|
|
| </sequence>
|
|
| </complexType>
|
|------------------------------------+------------------------------------|
|EventDescription
| <complexType
|
| [R] QName name
|name="EventDescription">
|
| [O] QName aliases[]
| <sequence>
|
| [O] QName type
| <element name="aliases"
|
| [O] anyURI schemaLocation |type="xsd:QName"
|
| [O] ModelTypes schemaType |minOccurs="0"
|
| [O] LocalizedString description |maxOccurs="unbounded"/>
|
| [O] LocalizedString hint |
<element name="description" |
| [O] LocalizedString label |type="types:LocalizedString"
|
| [O] Extension extensions |minOccurs="0"/>
|
|
|
<element name="label" |
|Should be [O] Extension extensions[]|type="types:LocalizedString"
|
|instead
|minOccurs="0"/>
|
|
|
<element name="hint" |
|
|type="types:LocalizedString"
|
|
|minOccurs="0"/>
|
|
|
<element name="schemaType" |
|
|type="types:ModelTypes"
|
|
|minOccurs="0"/>
|
|
|
<element name="extensions" |
|
|type="types:Extension"
|
|
|minOccurs="0"
|
|
|maxOccurs="unbounded"/>
|
|
| </sequence>
|
|
| <attribute
name="name" |
|
|type="xsd:QName"
use="required"/> |
|
| <attribute
name="type" |
|
|type="xsd:QName"
use="optional"/> |
|
| <attribute
name="schemaLocation"|
|
|type="xsd:anyURI"
use="optional"/> |
|
| </complexType>
|
|------------------------------------+------------------------------------|
|PropertyDescription
| <complexType
|
| [R] QName name
|name="PropertyDescription">
|
| [R] QName type
| <sequence>
|
| [O] anyURI schemaLocation |
<element name="description" |
| [O] LocalizedString description |type="types:LocalizedString"
|
| [O] LocalizedString label |minOccurs="0"/>
|
| [O] LocalizedString hint |
<element name="label"
|
| [O] string usage[]
|type="types:LocalizedString" |
| [O] QName aliases[]
|minOccurs="0"/>
|
| [O] Extension extensions |
<element name="hint"
|
|
|type="types:LocalizedString"
|
|Should be [O] Extension extensions[]|minOccurs="0"/>
|
|instead
| <element name="usage"
|
|
|type="xsd:string"
|
|
|minOccurs="0"
|
|
|maxOccurs="unbounded"/>
|
|
|
<element name="aliases" |
|
|type="xsd:QName"
|
|
|minOccurs="0"
|
|
|maxOccurs="unbounded"/>
|
|
|
<element name="extensions" |
|
|type="types:Extension"
|
|
|minOccurs="0"
|
|
|maxOccurs="unbounded"/>
|
|
| </sequence>
|
|
| <attribute
name="name" |
|
|type="xsd:QName"
use="required"/> |
|
| <attribute
name="type" |
|
|type="xsd:QName"
use="required"/> |
|
| <attribute
name="schemaLocation"|
|
|type="xsd:anyURI"
use="optional"/> |
|
| </complexType>
|
|------------------------------------+------------------------------------|
|ModelDescription
| <complexType
|
| [O] PropertyDescription |name="ModelDescription">
|
|propertyDescriptions[] |
<sequence>
|
| [O] ModelTypes modelTypes |
<element
|
| [O] Extension extensions |name="propertyDescriptions"
|
|
|type="types:PropertyDescription"
|
|Should be [O] Extension extensions[]|minOccurs="0"
|
|instead
|maxOccurs="unbounded"/>
|
|
|
<element name="modelTypes" |
|
|type="types:ModelTypes"
|
|
|minOccurs="0"/>
|
|
|
<element name="extensions" |
|
|type="types:Extension"
|
|
|minOccurs="0"
|
|
|maxOccurs="unbounded"/>
|
|
| </sequence>
|
|
| </complexType>
|
|------------------------------------+------------------------------------|
|Same pattern (extensions not an |
|
|array in spec):
|
|
|ParameterDescription
|
|
|PortletDescription
|
|
|PropertyList
|
|
|
|
|
|Should be [O] Extension extensions[]|
|
|instead
|
|
|------------------------------------+------------------------------------|
|ExtensionDescription
|<complexType
|
| [R] QName name
|name="ExtensionDescription">
|
| [R] ExtensionPart parts[] |
<sequence>
|
| [O] QName aliases[]
| <element name="parts"
|
| [O] LocalizedString description |type="types:ExtensionPart"
|
| [O] LocalizedString label |minOccurs="0"
|
| [O] LocalizedString hint |maxOccurs="unbounded"/>
|
| [O] Extension extensions[] |
<element name="aliases" |
|
|type="xsd:QName"
|
|Extension parts should be optional |minOccurs="0"
|
|
|maxOccurs="unbounded"/>
|
|
|
<element name="description" |
|
|type="types:LocalizedString"
|
|
|minOccurs="0"/>
|
|
|
<element name="label" |
|
|type="types:LocalizedString"
|
|
|minOccurs="0"/>
|
|
|
<element name="hint" |
|
|type="types:LocalizedString"
|
|
|minOccurs="0"/>
|
|
|
<element name="extensions" |
|
|type="types:Extension"
|
|
|minOccurs="0"
|
|
|maxOccurs="unbounded"/>
|
|
| </sequence>
|
|
| <attribute
name="name" |
|
|type="xsd:QName"
use="required"/> |
|
| </complexType>
|
|------------------------------------+------------------------------------|
|NamedString
|<complexType name="NamedString">
|
| [R] string name
| <sequence>
|
| [O] string value
| <element name="value"
|
|
|type="xsd:string"/>
|
|
| </sequence>
|
|
| <attribute
name="name" |
|
|type="xsd:string"
use="required"/> |
|
| </complexType>
|
|
|
|
|
|value should have
minoccurs="0" |
|------------------------------------+------------------------------------|
|ResourceParams
|
|
| [R] ID resourceID
|<complexType name="ResourceParams"> |
| [R] StateChange portletStateChange| <complexContent>
|
| [O] string resourceState |
<extension
|
| [O] string
|base="types:MimeRequest">
|
|resourceCacheability
| <sequence>
|
| [O] NamedString formParameters[] |
<element
|
| [O] UploadContext
|name="formParameters"
|
|uploadContexts[]
|type="types:NamedString"
|
|
|minOccurs="0"
maxOccurs="unbounded" |
|
|/>
|
|
|
<element
|
|
|name="uploadContexts"
|
|
|type="types:UploadContext"
|
|
|minOccurs="0"
maxOccurs="unbounded" |
|
|/>
|
|
|
</sequence>
|
|
|
<attribute name="resourceID"|
|
|type="xsd:string"
use="required"/> |
|
|
<attribute
|
|
|name="portletStateChange"
|
|
|type="types:StateChange"
|
|
|use="required"/>
|
|
|
<attribute
|
|
|name="resourceState"
|
|
|type="xsd:string"/>
|
|
|
<attribute
|
|
|name="resourceCacheability"
|
|
|type="xsd:string"/>
|
|
|
</extension>
|
|
| </complexContent>
|
|
| </complexType>
|
|
|
|
|
|resourceState &
resourceCachability |
|
|should be use="optional"
|
|------------------------------------+------------------------------------|
|ImportPortletsFailed
|<complexType name="BaseFailed"> |
| [R] ID importIDs[]
| <sequence>
|
| [R] ErrorCodes errorCode |
<element name="reason" |
| [R] LocalizedString reason |type="types:LocalizedString"
|
| [O] ResourceList resourceList|minOccurs="0"/>
|
| [O] Extension extensions[] |
<element name="resourceList" |
|
|type="types:ResourceList"
|
|reason should be optional |minOccurs="0"/>
|
|
|
<element name="extensions" |
|
|type="types:Extension"
|
|
|minOccurs="0"
|
|
|maxOccurs="unbounded"/>
|
|
| </sequence>
|
|
| <attribute
name="errorCode" |
|
|type="types:ErrorCodes"
|
|
|use="required"/>
|
|
| </complexType>
|
|
| <element
name="BaseFailed" |
|
|type="types:BaseFailed"/>
|
|
|
|
|
|<complexType
|
|
|name="ImportPortletsFailed">
|
|
| <complexContent>
|
|
|
<extension
|
|
|base="types:BaseFailed">
|
|
|
<sequence>
|
|
|
<element name="importID" |
|
|type="xsd:string"
|
|
|maxOccurs="unbounded"/>
|
|
|
</sequence>
|
|
|
</extension>
|
|
| </complexContent>
|
|
| </complexType>
|
|------------------------------------+------------------------------------|
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe from this mail list, you must leave the OASIS TC that
generates this mail. You may a link to this group and all your TCs
in OASIS
at:
https://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/portal/my_workgroups.php
Notice: This email message, together with any attachments, may contain
information of BEA Systems, Inc., its subsidiaries and affiliated entities,
that may be confidential, proprietary, copyrighted and/or legally privileged,
and is intended solely for the use of the individual or entity named in
this message. If you are not the intended recipient, and have received
this message in error, please immediately return this by email and then
delete it.
Notice: This email message, together with any attachments, may contain
information of BEA Systems, Inc., its subsidiaries and affiliated entities,
that may be confidential, proprietary, copyrighted and/or legally privileged,
and is intended solely for the use of the individual or entity named in
this message. If you are not the intended recipient, and have received
this message in error, please immediately return this by email and then
delete it.
[Date Prev]
| [Thread Prev]
| [Thread Next]
| [Date Next]
--
[Date Index]
| [Thread Index]
| [List Home]