[Date Prev] | [Thread Prev] | [Thread Next] | [Date Next] -- [Date Index] | [Thread Index] | [List Home]
Subject: WSS Minutes 2006-04-04
SUMMARY NEW ACTION ITEM: Chairs to start electronic ballot on approval of the updated 1.0 errata as Committee Draft. COMPLETED ACTION: Tony reviewed the minimalist profile and has the opinion that is no longer relevent. AGREED: Drop the minimalist profile work item. NEW ACTION ITEM: Tony to submit One Time Password algorithm. > Agenda: > REMINDER CALL WILL BE LIMITED TO ONE HOUR DUE TO WS-SX F2F > > 1. Call to order/roll call Michael McIntosh to take minutes Don Flinn took the role call > 2. Reading/Approving minutes of last meeting (21st March 2006)[1] Minutes read and approved - with addition of attendance > 3. SAML 2 Interop status Prateek not present to this item is defered until the next meeting. > 4. Issues list (if any issues) Kelvin asked Mike Rudolf to review the minutes of the last meeting for items that need to be tracked in the issues list. Tony posted updated 1.0 errata - moved to approve as CD via electronic ballot (majority of voting members) NEW ACTION ITEM: Chairs to start electronic ballot on approval of the updated 1.0 errata as Committee Draft. COMPLETED ACTION: Tony reviewed the minimalist profile and has the opinion that is no longer relevent. AGREED to drop the minimalist profile work item One Time Password Discussion Tony - initially was said we could not use UsernameToken to contain OTP, was said that addditional algorithm specifier was needed - now people as saying algorithm specifier is not needed. John - there is a need to optionally convey algorithm Chris - is it true that parameters are specific to each algorithm? John - different classes of algorithms need different parameters Hal - you can enumerate the total set of parameters then find the subset associated with a class of algorithm Paul - some where questioning the proprietary algorithms, Phil mistook that we wanted to get rid of all of the algorithms John - if we are designing a framework that is extensible why be concerned with any algorithms? Chris - for interop Mike - why isn't UsernameToken adequate? John - goal is to be able to able to provide parameters in a way that is visible Hal- when the profile was discussed people had said UsernameToken had not worked John - If you used UsernameToken you would need a new profile for each algorithm Hal - is there new work to do? does it involve new identifiers? and how much work is involved for each? John - the intent is to provide a range of parameters Hal - do we define identifiers for only documented algorithms? or do we include identifiers for undocumented/unspecified algorithms? Ron - is it that we want to include a single algorithm an dthere is IP behind them? Paul - several people pointed to the fact that the algorithms are trademarked and encumbered at the last meeting Ron - why not make that algorithm the baseline of interoperability? would the submitters not agree to at least one? John - the most common deployment situation will mean that the sending and receiving WSS node will not generate or validate the password Chris - do you have an answer to Ron's question? John - no. Tony - IBM will submit an algorithm that is RF for a default algorithm. Paul - wrt IPR statement made by submitters - action was that John would speak to Phil Hallem Baker - still pending? Jonh - in progress between companies. Chris - found statements from participants in RSA conference that is unclear wrt IPR on any other than RSA Paul - need an explicit list of action items - explicit IPR statement beyond initial submissions NEW ACTION ITEM: Tony to submit One Time Password algorithm Paul: Propose to not have a call until IPR statement is clarified Abbie: Seconded Ron: There are open issues re SAML profile Chris: Send issues to the list and we will decide whether to have a meeting in two weeks > 5. Remaining business for 2006 (continuing prior discussion) > 6. Other business > 7. Adjournment Mike: Moved to adjourn Frederick: Second Chris: Adjourned.
[Date Prev] | [Thread Prev] | [Thread Next] | [Date Next] -- [Date Index] | [Thread Index] | [List Home]