[xacml-comment] <AttributeValue> is optional or mandatory?

[Satoshi Hada <SATOSHIH@jp.ibm.com>]

Hi,

Section 6.7 says that <AttributeValue> is optional, but the schema
http://www.oasis-open.org/committees/xacml/repository/cs-xacml-schema-context-01.xsd

says that it is mandatory.

Which is correct?

Satoshi Hada
IBM Tokyo Research Laboratory
mailto:satoshih@jp.ibm.com



----------------------------------------------------------------
To subscribe or unsubscribe from this elist use the subscription
manager: <http://lists.oasis-open.org/ob/adm.pl>










Received: (qmail 19392 invoked by uid 60881); 20 Mar 2003 07:08:26 -0000
Received: from SATOSHIH@jp.ibm.com by hermes by uid 0 with qmail-scanner-1.15 
 (spamassassin: 2.43.  Clear:SA:0(0.8/8.0):. 
 Processed in 0.874031 secs); 20 Mar 2003 07:08:26 -0000
X-Spam-Status: No, hits=0.8 required=8.0
Received: from unknown (HELO georgia.yamato.ibm.com) (203.141.89.181)
  by mail.oasis-open.org with SMTP; 20 Mar 2003 07:08:25 -0000
Received: from e022f2n9.jp.ibm.com (d22relay01.yamato.ibm.com [9.68.14.52])
	by georgia.yamato.ibm.com (8.11.6/8.11.1) with ESMTP id h2K7GEw90268
	for <xacml-comment@lists.oasis-open.org>; Thu, 20 Mar 2003 16:16:14 +0900
Received: from e022f3n5 (d22hubm9 [9.68.14.47])
	by e022f2n9.jp.ibm.com (8.12.8/NCO/VER6.5) with ESMTP id h2K7GDxi093298
	for <xacml-comment@lists.oasis-open.org>; Thu, 20 Mar 2003 16:16:14 +0900
To: XACML COMMENT <xacml-comment@lists.oasis-open.org>
X-Mailer: Lotus Notes Release 5.07a  May 14, 2001
Message-ID: <OFB3C45185.A3B14D94-ON49256CEF.0027BFD9@LocalDomain>
From: "Satoshi Hada" <SATOSHIH@jp.ibm.com>
Date: Thu, 20 Mar 2003 16:16:11 +0900
Subject: Testcases for Relative XPath 
X-MIMETrack: Serialize by Router on D22HUBM9/22/H/IBM(Release 5.0.10 |March 22, 2002) at
 2003/03/20 04:16:13 PM
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-type: multipart/mixed; 
	Boundary="0__=C6BBE67CDFB439498f9e8a93df938690918cC6BBE67CDFB43949"
Content-Disposition: inline

--0__=C6BBE67CDFB439498f9e8a93df938690918cC6BBE67CDFB43949
Content-type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii

Hi,

I'd like to add two test cases: IIIF007 and IIIG006.
These are for testing relative XPath expressions.

(See attached file: IIIF.zip)(See attached file: IIIG.zip)

Satoshi Hada
IBM Tokyo Research Laboratory
mailto:satoshih@jp.ibm.com

--0__=C6BBE67CDFB439498f9e8a93df938690918cC6BBE67CDFB43949
Content-type: application/zip; 
	name="IIIF.zip"
Content-Disposition: attachment; filename="IIIF.zip"
Content-transfer-encoding: base64
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--0__=C6BBE67CDFB439498f9e8a93df938690918cC6BBE67CDFB43949
Content-type: application/zip; 
	name="IIIG.zip"
Content-Disposition: attachment; filename="IIIG.zip"
Content-transfer-encoding: base64
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--0__=C6BBE67CDFB439498f9e8a93df938690918cC6BBE67CDFB43949--