[xacml] CR summary from Anne

[Seth Proctor <seth.proctor@sun.com>]

CR Summary list from Anne attached ... she's having trouble w/email.


seth
Subject: Summary of Change Requests actions taken 11/7/02

Here is a list of the spec and schema changes that need to be
made as a result of the actions taken in the TC meeting on
UNRESOLVED Change Requests this morning.  If there is something I
missed or got wrong, please respond ASAP to the list!!!

-Anne

CR#0092: Section 7 on Attributes needs revision

-v0.18f already incorporates the revised text that Polar
 submitted.
-Add edits Anne supplied as follows:
  7.9.1 Attribute Matching, second sentence:

    "An attribute specifies AttributeId, DataType, and Issuer
                                                      ^optional
     attributes, and each named attribute also specifies
     AttributeId, DataType, and Issuer attributes.
                               ^optional

  7.9.1 Attribute Matching, fourth sentence and following:

    "The AttributeId attribute MUST match, by URI equality, that of
                              ^ of the named attribute      xxxxxxx
     the AttributeId attribute of the attribute."
                                     ^context attribute

     The DataType attribute MUST match, by URI equality, that of
                           ^of the named attribute       xxxxxxx
     the DataType attribute of the same attribute.
                                       ^context
     If the Issuer attribute is supplied, it MUST match, by URI
                                        ^in the named attribute
     equality, the Issuer attribute of the same attribute.
                                               ^context
     If the Issuer attribute is not supplied in the named
     attribute, the matching of the attribute to the named
                                   ^context
     attribute SHALL be governed by ...
     In the case of the attribute selector, the matching of the...
                    xxx^an

  7.9.4 Subject Attributes

    "A conformant implementation MUST support the subject category
     attribute, which is an attribute with the criteria of an
                                           xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
     AttributeId of ...

CR#0146: Function "present" needs to be fixed
-All *AttributeDesignators and AttributeSelector have XML
 attribute "MustBePresent".  Semantics are explained in "7.9.2
 AttributeRetrieval"
-Section 5.24 Element <Apply>
 Remove all references to *IsPresent elements
-Remove Section 5.30 Element <ResourceAttributeIsPresent>
-Remove Section 5.31 Element <ActionAttributeIsPresent>
-Remove Section 5.32 Element <EnvironmentAttributeIsPresent>
-Remove Section 5.34 Element <SubjectyAttributeIsPresent>
-Update Section 10.3.1 Schema Elements

CR#0154: SubjectQualifier/SubjectAttributeDesignatorWhere
-Remove all references to QualifiedSubjectAttributeDesignator (and
 old name of SubjectAttributeDesignatorWhere)
-Remove all references to SubjectQualifiery
-Use "SubjectAttributeDesignator", rather than proposed
 "CategorizedSubjectAttributeDesignator"
-In general, Multiple <Subject> elements with same
 subject-category are permitted, but SubjectAttributeDesignator
 treats all Attributes in all <Subject> elements that have the
 same subject-category XML attribute as if they were the same
 <Subject>.  AttributeSelector may be used to distinguish between
 them if desired.

CR#0156: ObligationType
-Editorial change already incorporated

CR#0157:Glitch in moving from decimal to double
-Reference to IBMSDA already replaced with reference to IEEE 754.
-Remove any other reference to IBMSDA

CR#0162: Subjects
-Same as CR#0154

-- 
Anne H. Anderson             Email: Anne.Anderson@Sun.COM
Sun Microsystems Laboratories
1 Network Drive,UBUR02-311     Tel: 781/442-0928
Burlington, MA 01803-0902 USA  Fax: 781/442-1692