Re: [xacml] Minutes of 18 March 2004 XACML TC Meeting

[Frank Siebenlist <franks@mcs.anl.gov>]

 > WI #36: Frank will review the item.

Being put on the spot this morning with a peanut butter jar in my hand (no 
joking), I wasn't able to grasp the depth of WI#36 well ... now with my laptop 
and a second double espresso in front of me, it's clear that WI#36 is part of 
the grand admin/delegation plan and should therefor be addressed at the F2F.

-Frank.




Bill Parducci wrote:

> XACML TC General Body Meeting Minutes
> 18 March 2004; Time: 10:00 AM EDT
> 
> Attendees:
> Anne Anderson
> Hal Lockhart
> Michiharu Kudo
> Tim Moses
> Simon Godik
> Daniel Engovatov
> Seth Proctor
> Polar Humenn
> Frank Siebenlist
> Bill Parducci
> Tony Nadalin
> 
> Quorum reached.
> 
> Agenda:
> 
> 1. Minutes from 4 March meeting voted upon. Approved unanimously.
> 
> 2. Hal: ITU-T Meeting Summary
> Last Thursday & Friday Karl Best & Hal wen to ITU-T met with Study Group 
> 17:
> ASN-1 Communication Security, X.500 directory. Karl provided an overview of
> Oasis, Hal presented SAML & XACML to all groups. Revisited each group
> individually. Most relevant group to the adoption of our work is 
> Communication &
> Security group. They have not had enough time to review the SAML & XACML 
> spec in
> detail yet.  Current thinking is that future direction will be based around
> possible Profile derived from work generated by ITU-T and refined with 
> Oasis
> groups. Culmination of this work may happen in roughly a year or so. A more
> formal agreement will be coming from the ITU-T in the next week or so.
> 
> 3. <IssueInstant>
> Brief discussion on this element, with the consensus of it being an 
> artifact of
> a previous attempt tot address time intervals that was not fully flushed 
> out.
> Anne moved that we remove it, Polar seconded. Voted upon. Approved 
> unanimously.
> 
> 4. Documentation Update (Tim Moses)
> Working on Draft 7, to be released by the end of the week. "Variable 
> Definition"
> modifications are far reaching so there is a good chance there will be some
> ramifications that are not caught in this release. REQUEST: the Champion 
> of Work
> Item are asked to review the ENTIRE document to ensure that his Work 
> Item is
> properly presented and referenced thought the specification. Further, each
> Champion is begin asked to send a note to Tim or the list to verify that 
> content
> is indeed correct.
> 
> 5. SAML Interaction Update (Anne Anderson)
> Eve Mahler i of SAML has come up with an attribute mapping mechanism that
> appears to address the problem. When this has gelled, XACML may wish to 
> revisit
> the implications. Hal proposed that create a Work Item. WI #64 has been 
> created.
> WI #65 was also created to address Source definitions.
> 
> 6. Work Items (Anne Anderson)
> 
> WI #36: Frank will review the item.
> 
> WI #31: Will be addressed at next F2F
> 
> WI #29: Will be addressed at next F2F
> 
> WI #62: Suggested by TC that "substring" function be based upon Well Known
> mechanism (Regular Expressions in the case). Seth will work on writing up
> something to address this
> 
> WI #61 - closed for 2.0
> 
> WI #58 - Anne will continue to work on this
> 
> WI #46 - Seth proposed that a textual explanation in the specification 
> may serve
> the purpose better of addressing a missing attribute value than 
> modifying the
> schema - Polar proposed that this be handled via a succinct attribute in 
> the
> [recent] absence of <IssueInstant>. ACTION: Seth will follow up on this.
> 
> ACTION: Anne will create a proposal to address IP Address matching
> 
> Tim confirmed that the <Expression> tag be marked FINAL to prevent 
> extension.
> Agreed upon by TC.
> 
> Tim asked that WRT example Rule 1 (posted yesterday) if the child of 
> <AttributeValue> needs to be XML, not text and is uncertain whether it 
> should be xs:string, or xsi:string.  He is looking for guidance for from 
> an XMagician type as to which is correct.
> 
> Meeting Adjourned.
> 
> 
> To unsubscribe from this mailing list (and be removed from the roster of 
> the OASIS TC), go to 
> http://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/xacml/members/leave_workgroup.php. 
> 
> 

-- 
Frank Siebenlist               franks@mcs.anl.gov
The Globus Alliance - Argonne National Laboratory