Subject: Minutes 11 September TC Meeting
1. Roll Call Hal Lockhart (minutes) Bill Parducci (Co-chair, minutes) Erik Rissanen Anthony Nadalin Rich Levinson Hal Lockhart Anil Saldhana John Tolbert Duane DeCouteau (non-voting) Quorum reached 7 of 9 (77%) 2. Administrivia Vote on minutes postponed to next meeting due to late posting to list. 3. Issues Open Issues on list http://lists.oasis-open.org/archives/xacml/200809/msg00000.html The TC has no objections to those Issues Erik suggests should be considered No Action. The TC has no objections to the Proposed Actions Erik presented on the list. Identifier conflict ‚Äì the TC has chosen to resolve this by using: urn:oasis:names:tc:xacml:1.0:subject:authentication-method String comparison - the general consensus is this issue requires more consideration. A possible source is XQuery's implementation. Multiply function arguments - The TC agrees that 0 or 1 argument will not be supported. The TC also agrees that Add and Multiply arguments will BOTH allow multiple arguments in v3. V2 will not be updated. The identifier will remain the same in V3. Interger overflow - The TC agreed that interger overflow during upon type conversion should be handled as an Indeterminate result. Rule combining algorithms - The TC will create simpler text description to describe combining algorithms as suggested on the list. The pseudo code will be listed as non-normative. Issue 72 SAML:Where should passed-in policies be inserted Hal noted that the spec currently says that there is a top level combining algorithm in an implied policy set. The TC decided that the provided policies shall be inserted in the presented order at the top of this policy set. Hal took an action item to propose text which would include more explicit wording on the TLP set. Issue 75: Defining an interface for closely coupled PEP/PDP This will not be considered part of the core schema, rather it will be addressed via a Profile. This is not on the V3 critical path. Issue 66: Missing attributes may be underspecified This will discussed further on the list and will be taken up on the next call. meeting adjourned.