[Date Prev] | [Thread Prev] | [Thread Next] | [Date Next] -- [Date Index] | [Thread Index] | [List Home]
Subject: Re: [xcbf] Chair and Editorhould
John, I appreciate the suggestion and offer. However, my work requirements would not allow me to take on the chairmanship. Thank you. Monica John Larmouth wrote: > Now that Phil has confirmed that he really *is* resigning, I believe > we need to think for a momenent about what we want from a new Chair > and Editor. > > I think the primary requirement for the Chair is someone who will take > full account of the views of the membership of the TC, and produce > the technical direction needed for a consensus document to be produced > with zero NO votes (and will not ballot until that consensus is > reasonably well secured). > > I am not going to critise Phil (OK, so I am!) but we have rushed into > too many votes before there was a consensus. > > I believe the only real requirement for the Editor is someone that is > prepared to do the editing work, and understands that text has to be > unambiguous, and consistent with standards it references. (The Chair > has to play a part in that as well, but the Editor should play a > controlling roll here.) > > Knowledge of OASIS procedures is also very desirable for the Chair. > Less important for the Editor. In neither case do I see technical > knowledge (except in broad terms) of the area as important. That > should be provided by the membership, and if Phil remains a member, he > will surely provide such input. Both the Chair and Editor roles are > supportive and facilitating for the work - or should be. (It would be > better for Phil and everyone else if Phil provided his technical input > as a member of the TC, not as the Chair and Editor. But I do not need > to make that point, Phil has already resigned from both posts.) > > As a purely personal view (and I have not spoken to Monica - sorry > Monica!), I think that Monica would fit ths spec for a Chair, if she > is willing to do it. (I knmow she is involved in many other groups, > and may feel she does not have the time, but here involvement in other > related groups also very much strengthens here as a candidate for the > Chair.) > > I have already nominated Paul Thorpe for the Editor post. I am > absolutely sere he would do an excellent job, and would fully support > whoever is appointed as the Chair. > > **** I am sure this is not the right way to do nominations in formal > terms, but consensus is better than formal procedures. **** Comments > are invited. > > I also believe that further meetings of the group before the new Chair > (and perhapas also the Editor) are appointed would nbot be a good idea > - other than to discuss the criteria we want for selecting a Chair and > Editor. > > Enough for now!!!! > > John L >
[Date Prev] | [Thread Prev] | [Thread Next] | [Date Next] -- [Date Index] | [Thread Index] | [List Home]