Fwd: The Great Symbol Swap

["=Drummond Reed" <drummond.reed@xdi.org>]

Some feedback from Andy Dale at Respect Network.

---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: Andy Dale <andy@respectnetwork.net>
Date: Thu, Feb 27, 2014 at 11:33 PM
Subject: Re: The Great Symbol Swap
To: =Drummond Reed <drummond.reed@xdi.org>

My 10 cents:

I like the # for the dictionary space. I think that the common usage of "hashtag" actually maps fairly well "finally home #home"... =drummond#home

This would move the @ to the numbered element of a collection which also works for me as @ = 'at': I want the email at position 1... [#email]@1

Clearly these are both rationalizations but, to me they seem as good as any.

Andy

On Thu, Feb 27, 2014 at 11:07 PM, =Drummond Reed <drummond.reed@xdi.org> wrote:

In an XDI-related marketing meeting last Tuesday, the marketers in attendance came up with a dramatic new idea: changing the XDI context symbol for organizational/legal identifiers from @ to +.

The reason is simply that Twitter has created a defacto usage of @identifiers. By switching from @ to +:

1. Any perceptual or branding conflict with @identifiers would be eliminated.
2. We keep the personal and organizational/legal namespaces completely separated (as has always been our intention).
   
3. The + symbol has a nice symbiosis with = (both are mathematical symbols).
4. + has the connotation of "partnership".

If other XDI TC members agree about this, it leaves the question of what should become the context symbol for the dictionary space. There are 4 basic options:

1. Use the @ symbol, e.g., =drummond@home, =drummond@home<@email>
2. Use the * symbol, e.g., =drummond*home, =drummond*home<*email>
3. Use the # symbol, e.g., =drummond#home, =drummond#home<#email>
4. Use the $ symbol, e.g., =drummond$home, =drummond$home<$email>

In the first case, it would be a direct swap of + and @. This would have the minimum impact on existing code bases.

In the other three cases, we'd have a three way symbol swap.

This is obviously an important change, so I'm going to put in on the agenda for tomorrow's  XDI TC call.

=Drummond