csprd03 - Constraints in 5.5.4.3 resourceItemRef and 5.5.4.4 resourceItem

["Schnabel, Bryan S" <bryan.s.schnabel@tektronix.com>]

The constraints in 5.5.4.3 resourceItemRef and 5.5.4.4 resourceItem say “The value of the OPTIONAL id attribute MUST be unique among all <resourceItem> and <resourceItemRef> elements of the immediate enclosing <file> or <unit> element.” Since we agreed to make <res:resourceData> Zero or One for <file> and <unit>, there will never be a case where sibling <res:resourceData> elements have potentially conflicting @id values for <res:resourceItemRef> or <res:resourceItem>. So the only conflict that could be impacted (and this seems like a nearly non-existent use case) is if for some reason FragID needed to discern between them. Seems like a lot of baggage to support such a corner case. I suggest we either (1) remove the constraint all together, or (2) edit the constraint to say ” The value of the OPTIONAL id attribute MUST be unique among all <resourceItem> and <resourceItemRef> elements of the enclosing <res:resourceData> element.”