[Date Prev] | [Thread Prev] | [Thread Next] | [Date Next] -- [Date Index] | [Thread Index] | [List Home]
Subject: RE: [xliff] Section 2.6.7 "Target Content Modification" - Split/Merge
Hi Jung, Fredrik, all, > The sentence in 2.6.7.1 should be removed. Or reworded to > say that the user agent may leave the segment without a target. +1. > On 2.6.7.2: Regarding the current rules on splitting and joining. > ... > And I do not think you are alone in wanting to do so. This all > comes down to the dynamic vs. static behavior of the <segment> > and <ignorable> elements. I think having some kind of mechanism that indicates a unit should not be re-segmented would be perfectly acceptable. This type of requirement exists for example in XLIFF:doc from Interoperability Now. this notion is also listed in our wiki (See the section "Segment modification" in https://wiki.oasis-open.org/xliff/XLIFF2.0/Feature/Segmentation). We had no discussion on this until now, but that doesn't mean we should not. > An alternative to the attributes on segment that I feel is > cleaner is to leverage the static structure property of <unit>. > If you have non sub dividable pieces that you want to preserve > they should be put in a <unit> each and in the <unit> you put > a single <segment>. I would prefer to use some unit-level attribute than re-purpose the group/unit. Hinting that putting the segment representation may be done that way would somewhat go against the idea of having only one way to do one thing. I'd rather have a clear attribute that indicate what re-segmentation operation can be done on a unit. An extra note for the Inline-SC members: This discussion is related to text in a sub-section that lives in the "Inline Content" section, but it concerns more the general structure than the inline markup. I think any potential change here would not affect the overall inline markup proposals. So I think we can proceed in the SC with moving our proposals to the TC. cheers, -yves
[Date Prev] | [Thread Prev] | [Thread Next] | [Date Next] -- [Date Index] | [Thread Index] | [List Home]