[Date Prev] | [Thread Prev] | [Thread Next] | [Date Next] -- [Date Index] | [Thread Index] | [List Home]
Subject: Re: [xliff] xml:lang
Thanks, Yves, inlineOn Tue, Jan 21, 2014 at 12:23 PM, Yves Savourel <firstname.lastname@example.org> wrote:
Hi David, all,
I assume that for target you meant to write:
“the value defined by the trgLang attribute on <file>.”I meant to write trglang obn <xliff>
Also for the constraint: There is no reason to forbid xml:lang on elements that do not affect the <source> and <target> inheritance. For example one may want to specify the language of a <note> element. So xml:lang should be prohibited only on <file>, <group> and <unit>. And, I suppose, on <mtc:match>.I agree, I added the constraint prohibitting setting it on <file>, <group> and <unit>You are right we do not want to constarin it on other nodes that do not affect the inheritanceYou can check the file on svnno printout yet, I edited just the xml_lang.xml file
Hello all, I promised I will be back with a proposal for xml:lang that we have so far neglected as the discussion concentrated on xml:space.
I believe that the following should be done
xml:lang defaults should be changed
to value defined in srcLang on the xliff elemenet
Currently, people not defining xml:lang on source or target leave it undefined, which is clearly wrong
Adding a Constraint
xml:lang MUST NOT be set at core extension points.
Setting the value would conflict with srcLang and trgLang semantics
I am going to implement and print this before the meeting, please shout no later than in the meeting if you think this is wrong or you have a better solution