OASIS Mailing List ArchivesView the OASIS mailing list archive below
or browse/search using MarkMail.

 


Help: OASIS Mailing Lists Help | MarkMail Help

xslt-conformance message

[Date Prev] | [Thread Prev] | [Thread Next] | [Date Next] -- [Date Index] | [Thread Index] | [Elist Home]


Subject: reports


Hi All:
 
    After taking into account Ben's and David comments, please see the
attached xml data (make believe) and reports that MAY be derived from it
to track the review progress.  Please note that "report2" is indexed by
reviewer and still list both reviewers (which cause a test to appear
more than once in the report.  That could easily be fixed, however I
wanted to get feedback first). 
 
Greetings,
Carmelo Montanez
 
 
Carmelo Montanez
NIST Stop 8970
Gaithersburg, MD 20899
 
carmelo@nist.gov
<?xml version = "1.0" encoding = "UTF-8"?>
 <revisions>
   <statusflags>
     <statusflag id = "s0" displayname= "non-concensus"/>
     <statusflag id = "s1" displayname = "accepted"/>
     <statusflag id = "s2" displayname = "rejected"/>
     <statusflag id = "s3" displayname = "remanded"/>
     <statusflag id = "s4" displayname = "referred"/>
     <statusflag id = "s5" displayname = "under-review-need-one-decision"/>
     <statusflag id = "s6" displayname = "under-review-need-two-decision"/>
   </statusflags>
    <test status="s3" id ="Numb001">
     <explanation>Missing "name" attribute</explanation>
     <test-reviewer review-date="2001-07-05">Carmelo Montanez</test-reviewer>
     <test-reviewer review-date="2001-07-04">Ken Hollman</test-reviewer>
     <test-date>2001-06-01</test-date>
     <test-submitter>David Martson</test-submitter>
     <comments>Problem was reported back to organization</comments>
    </test>
    <test status="s1" id="Numb002">
     <test-reviewer review-date="2001-07-05">Carmelo Montanez</test-reviewer>
     <test-reviewer review-date="2001-07-06">Ben Robb</test-reviewer>
     <test-date>2001-06-01</test-date>
     <test-submitter>Dave Marston</test-submitter>
     <comments>No problems founded with Test</comments>
    </test>
    <test status="s3" id="Numb003">
     <explanation>Invalid token at line 10.</explanation>
     <test-reviewer review-date="2001-06-05">Carmelo Montanez</test-reviewer>
     <test-reviewer review-date="2001-06-05">Lynda Van Vleet</test-reviewer>
     <test-date>2001-06-02</test-date>
     <test-submitter>Dave Marston</test-submitter>
     <comments>Problem was reported back to organization</comments>
    </test>  
    <test status="s4" id="Numb004">
     <explanation>This test contains XSLT 2.0 features.</explanation>
     <test-reviewer review-date="2001-07-06">Carmelo Montanez</test-reviewer>
     <test-reviewer review-date="2001-06-10">Norman Walsh</test-reviewer>
     <test-date>2001-06-03</test-date>
     <test-submitter>Dave Marston</test-submitter>
     <comments>Notification of action was given to organization</comments>
    </test>
    <test status="s5" id="Numb005">
     <explanation>None</explanation>
     <test-reviewer review-date="2001-07-06">Carmelo Montanez</test-reviewer>
     <test-reviewer review-date="2001-07-11">Ben Robb</test-reviewer>
     <test-date>2001-06-03</test-date>
     <test-submitter>Dave Marston</test-submitter>
     <comments>None.</comments>
    </test>  
    <test status="s6" id="Numb006">
     <explanation>None.</explanation>
     <test-reviewer review-date="2001-07-07">Cris Cooley</test-reviewer>
     <test-reviewer review-date="2001-07-09">Lynda Van Vleet</test-reviewer>
     <test-date>2001-06-04</test-date>
     <test-submitter>Dave Marston</test-submitter>
     <comments>None.</comments>
    </test>
    <test status="s1" id="Numb007">
     <test-reviewer review-date="2001-06-09">Ken Hollman</test-reviewer>
     <test-reviewer review-date="2001-06-30">Lynda Van Vleet</test-reviewer>
     <test-date>2001-06-05</test-date>
     <test-submitter>Dave Marston</test-submitter>
     <comments>No problems founded with Test</comments>
    </test>
    <test status="s1" id="Numb008">
     <test-reviewer review-date="2001-07-08">Ken Hollman</test-reviewer>
     <test-reviewer review-date="2001-07-21">Lofton Henderson</test-reviewer>
     <test-date>2001-06-05</test-date>
     <test-submitter>Carmelo Montanez</test-submitter>
     <comments>No problems founded with Test</comments>
    </test>
    <test status="s3" id ="Numb009">
     <explanation>Missing "state" attribute</explanation>
     <test-reviewer review-date="2001-07-20">Carmelo Montanez</test-reviewer>
     <test-reviewer review-date="2001-08-01">Cris Cooley</test-reviewer>
     <test-date>2001-06-07</test-date>
     <test-submitter>David Martson</test-submitter>
     <comments>Problem was reported back to organization</comments>
    </test>
    <test status="s3" id ="Numb010">
     <explanation>Test is not conforming</explanation>
     <test-reviewer review-date="2001-07-21">Carmelo Montanez</test-reviewer>
     <test-reviewer review-date="2001-07-18">Dave Marston</test-reviewer>
     <test-date>2001-04-07</test-date>
     <test-submitter>Cris Cooley</test-submitter>
     <comments>Problem was reported back to submitting organization</comments>
    </test>
    <test status="s2" id="Numb011">
     <explanation>Missing namespace for "if" statement</explanation>
     <test-reviewer review-date="2001-07-05">Dave Marston</test-reviewer>
     <test-reviewer review-date="2001-07-01">Lofton Henderson</test-reviewer>
     <test-date>2001-06-02</test-date>
     <test-submitter>Lynda Van Vleet</test-submitter>
     <comments>Problem was reported back to organization</comments>
    </test>  
    <test status="s2" id="Numb012">
     <explanation>Invalid token at line 11.</explanation>
     <test-reviewer review-date="2001-07-09">Carmelo Montanez</test-reviewer>
     <test-reviewer review-date="2001-07-17">Ken Hollman</test-reviewer>
     <test-date>2001-04-02</test-date>
     <test-submitter>Lofton Henderson</test-submitter>
     <comments>Problem was reported back to Lotus.</comments>
    </test>  
    <test status="s4" id="Numb013">
     <explanation>None</explanation>
     <test-reviewer review-date="2001-07-10">Ken Hollman</test-reviewer>
     <test-reviewer review-date="2001-08-01">Dave Marston</test-reviewer>
     <test-date>2001-06-08</test-date>
     <test-submitter>Carmelo Montanez</test-submitter>
     <comments>None.</comments>
    </test> 
    <test status="s6" id="Numb014">
     <explanation>None</explanation>
     <test-reviewer review-date="2001-07-01">Norman Walsh</test-reviewer>
     <test-reviewer review-date="2001-07-09">Lynda Van Vleet</test-reviewer>
     <test-date>June 3, 2001-06-03</test-date>
     <test-submitter>Dave Marston</test-submitter>
     <comments>None.</comments>
    </test>
    <test status="s4" id="Numb015">
     <explanation>Tested feature is optional</explanation>
     <test-reviewer review-date="2001-07-09">Kirill Gavrylyuk</test-reviewer>
     <test-reviewer review-date="2001-07-19">Carmelo Montanez</test-reviewer>
     <test-date>2001-06-02</test-date>
     <test-submitter>Lynda Van Vleet</test-submitter>
     <comments>Notification of action was given to organization</comments>
    </test> 
    <test status="s0" id="Numb016">
     <explanation>Tested feature is unclear</explanation>
     <test-reviewer review-date="2001-07-09">Kirill Gavrylyuk</test-reviewer>
     <test-reviewer review-date="2001-07-19">Carmelo Montanez</test-reviewer>
     <test-date>2001-06-02</test-date>
     <test-submitter>Lynda Van Vleet</test-submitter>
     <comments>Discussion still on-going</comments>
    </test>
    <test status="s0" id="Numb017">
     <explanation>Unclear behavior for tested feature</explanation>
     <test-reviewer review-date="2001-07-09">Kirill Gavrylyuk</test-reviewer>
     <test-reviewer review-date="2001-0719">Carmelo Montanez</test-reviewer>
     <test-date>2001-06-02</test-date>
     <test-submitter>Lynda Van Vleet</test-submitter>
     <comments>on-going discussion</comments>
    </test> 
 </revisions>     
Title: XSLT/XPath Test Suite Problem Tracking Mechanism.

XSLT/XPath Test Suite Review Tracking Mechanism.

Tests Sorted by Status

Date: September 28, 2001

Accepted Tests

Test idSumbitterTest DateReviewer(s)/review-dateExplanation
Numb002Dave Marston2001-06-01Carmelo Montanez / 2001-07-05
Ben Robb / 2001-07-06
None
Numb007Dave Marston2001-06-05Ken Hollman / 2001-06-09
Lynda Van Vleet / 2001-06-30
None
Numb008Carmelo Montanez2001-06-05Ken Hollman / 2001-07-08
Lofton Henderson / 2001-07-21
None

Rejected Tests

Test idSumbitterTest DateReviewer(s)/review-dateExplanation
Numb011Lynda Van Vleet2001-06-02Dave Marston / 2001-07-05
Lofton Henderson / 2001-07-01
Missing namespace for "if" statement
Numb012Lofton Henderson2001-04-02Carmelo Montanez / 2001-07-09
Ken Hollman / 2001-07-17
Invalid token at line 11.

Remanded Tests

Test idSumbitterTest DateReviewer(s)/review-dateExplanation
Numb001David Martson2001-06-01Carmelo Montanez / 2001-07-05
Ken Hollman / 2001-07-04
Missing "name" attribute
Numb003Dave Marston2001-06-02Carmelo Montanez / 2001-06-05
Lynda Van Vleet / 2001-06-05
Invalid token at line 10.
Numb009David Martson2001-06-07Carmelo Montanez / 2001-07-20
Cris Cooley / 2001-08-01
Missing "state" attribute
Numb010Cris Cooley2001-04-07Carmelo Montanez / 2001-07-21
Dave Marston / 2001-07-18
Test is not conforming

Deferred Tests

Test idSumbitterTest DateReviewer(s)/review-dateExplanation
Numb004Dave Marston2001-06-03Carmelo Montanez / 2001-07-06
Norman Walsh / 2001-06-10
This test contains XSLT 2.0 features.
Numb013Carmelo Montanez2001-06-08Ken Hollman / 2001-07-10
Dave Marston / 2001-08-01
None
Numb015Lynda Van Vleet2001-06-02Kirill Gavrylyuk / 2001-07-09
Carmelo Montanez / 2001-07-19
Tested feature is optional

Tests Under Review in Need of one Decision

Test idSumbitterTest DateReviewer(s)/review-dateExplanation
Numb005Dave Marston2001-06-03Carmelo Montanez / 2001-07-06
Ben Robb / 2001-07-11
None

Tests Under Review in Need of two Decisions

Test idSumbitterTest DateReviewer(s)/review-dateExplanation
Numb006Dave Marston2001-06-04Cris Cooley / 2001-07-07
Lynda Van Vleet / 2001-07-09
None.
Numb014Dave MarstonJune 3, 2001-06-03Norman Walsh / 2001-07-01
Lynda Van Vleet / 2001-07-09
None

Tests Without a Concensus Decision

Test idSumbitterTest DateReviewer(s)/review-dateExplanation
Numb016Lynda Van Vleet2001-06-02Kirill Gavrylyuk / 2001-07-09
Carmelo Montanez / 2001-07-19
Tested feature is unclear
Numb017Lynda Van Vleet2001-06-02Kirill Gavrylyuk / 2001-07-09
Carmelo Montanez / 2001-0719
Unclear behavior for tested feature
Title: XSLT/XPath Test Suite Problem Tracking Mechanism.

XSLT/XPath Test Suite Review Tracking Mechanism.

Tests Sorted by Reviewer

Date: September 28, 2001

Ken Hollman

Test idSubmitterTest DateReviewer(s)/review-dateExplanation
Numb001David Martson2001-06-01Carmelo Montanez / 2001-07-05
Ken Hollman / 2001-07-04
Missing "name" attribute
Numb007Dave Marston2001-06-05Ken Hollman / 2001-06-09
Lynda Van Vleet / 2001-06-30
None
Numb008Carmelo Montanez2001-06-05Ken Hollman / 2001-07-08
Lofton Henderson / 2001-07-21
None
Numb012Lofton Henderson2001-04-02Carmelo Montanez / 2001-07-09
Ken Hollman / 2001-07-17
Invalid token at line 11.
Numb013Carmelo Montanez2001-06-08Ken Hollman / 2001-07-10
Dave Marston / 2001-08-01
None

Carmelo Montanez

Test idSubmitterTest DateReviewer(s)/review-dateExplanation
Numb001David Martson2001-06-01Carmelo Montanez / 2001-07-05
Ken Hollman / 2001-07-04
Missing "name" attribute
Numb002Dave Marston2001-06-01Carmelo Montanez / 2001-07-05
Ben Robb / 2001-07-06
None
Numb003Dave Marston2001-06-02Carmelo Montanez / 2001-06-05
Lynda Van Vleet / 2001-06-05
Invalid token at line 10.
Numb004Dave Marston2001-06-03Carmelo Montanez / 2001-07-06
Norman Walsh / 2001-06-10
This test contains XSLT 2.0 features.
Numb005Dave Marston2001-06-03Carmelo Montanez / 2001-07-06
Ben Robb / 2001-07-11
None
Numb009David Martson2001-06-07Carmelo Montanez / 2001-07-20
Cris Cooley / 2001-08-01
Missing "state" attribute
Numb010Cris Cooley2001-04-07Carmelo Montanez / 2001-07-21
Dave Marston / 2001-07-18
Test is not conforming
Numb012Lofton Henderson2001-04-02Carmelo Montanez / 2001-07-09
Ken Hollman / 2001-07-17
Invalid token at line 11.
Numb015Lynda Van Vleet2001-06-02Kirill Gavrylyuk / 2001-07-09
Carmelo Montanez / 2001-07-19
Tested feature is optional
Numb016Lynda Van Vleet2001-06-02Kirill Gavrylyuk / 2001-07-09
Carmelo Montanez / 2001-07-19
Tested feature is unclear
Numb017Lynda Van Vleet2001-06-02Kirill Gavrylyuk / 2001-07-09
Carmelo Montanez / 2001-0719
Unclear behavior for tested feature

David Marston

Test idSubmitterTest DateReviewer(s)/review-dateExplanation
Numb010Cris Cooley2001-04-07Carmelo Montanez / 2001-07-21
Dave Marston / 2001-07-18
Test is not conforming
Numb011Lynda Van Vleet2001-06-02Dave Marston / 2001-07-05
Lofton Henderson / 2001-07-01
Missing namespace for "if" statement
Numb013Carmelo Montanez2001-06-08Ken Hollman / 2001-07-10
Dave Marston / 2001-08-01
None

Lynda Van Vleet

Test idSubmitterTest DateReviewer(s)/review-dateExplanation
Numb003Dave Marston2001-06-02Carmelo Montanez / 2001-06-05
Lynda Van Vleet / 2001-06-05
Invalid token at line 10.
Numb006Dave Marston2001-06-04Cris Cooley / 2001-07-07
Lynda Van Vleet / 2001-07-09
None.
Numb007Dave Marston2001-06-05Ken Hollman / 2001-06-09
Lynda Van Vleet / 2001-06-30
None
Numb014Dave MarstonJune 3, 2001-06-03Norman Walsh / 2001-07-01
Lynda Van Vleet / 2001-07-09
None

Lofton Henderson

Test idSubmitterTest DateReviewer(s)/review-dateExplanation
Numb008Carmelo Montanez2001-06-05Ken Hollman / 2001-07-08
Lofton Henderson / 2001-07-21
None
Numb011Lynda Van Vleet2001-06-02Dave Marston / 2001-07-05
Lofton Henderson / 2001-07-01
Missing namespace for "if" statement

Ben Robb

Test idSubmitterTest DateReviewer(s)/review-dateExplanation
Numb002Dave Marston2001-06-01Carmelo Montanez / 2001-07-05
Ben Robb / 2001-07-06
None
Numb005Dave Marston2001-06-03Carmelo Montanez / 2001-07-06
Ben Robb / 2001-07-11
None

Kirill Gavrylyuk

Test idSubmitterTest DateReviewer(s)/review-dateExplanation
Numb015Lynda Van Vleet2001-06-02Kirill Gavrylyuk / 2001-07-09
Carmelo Montanez / 2001-07-19
Tested feature is optional
Numb016Lynda Van Vleet2001-06-02Kirill Gavrylyuk / 2001-07-09
Carmelo Montanez / 2001-07-19
Tested feature is unclear
Numb017Lynda Van Vleet2001-06-02Kirill Gavrylyuk / 2001-07-09
Carmelo Montanez / 2001-0719
Unclear behavior for tested feature

Cris Cooley

Test idSubmitterTest DateReviewer(s)/review-dateExplanation
Numb006Dave Marston2001-06-04Cris Cooley / 2001-07-07
Lynda Van Vleet / 2001-07-09
None.
Numb009David Martson2001-06-07Carmelo Montanez / 2001-07-20
Cris Cooley / 2001-08-01
Missing "state" attribute

Norman Walsh

Test idSubmitterTest DateReviewer(s)/review-dateExplanation
Numb004Dave Marston2001-06-03Carmelo Montanez / 2001-07-06
Norman Walsh / 2001-06-10
This test contains XSLT 2.0 features.
Numb014Dave MarstonJune 3, 2001-06-03Norman Walsh / 2001-07-01
Lynda Van Vleet / 2001-07-09
None


[Date Prev] | [Thread Prev] | [Thread Next] | [Date Next] -- [Date Index] | [Thread Index] | [Elist Home]


Powered by eList eXpress LLC