There should be no problem in adding
the missing sections from your proposal to the template that we
used in the IDCloud TC. If your proposal is useful for business
usecases, I do not think there is any issue in extending the
template.
On 02/18/2013 07:43 AM, Mike Poulin wrote:
Hi
All,
it is happening that in this TC I constantly take a position
of an opponent. Please, tell me if you have better
expalanation for this but I think that the reason for this
is in that I am looking at all we do from the architectural
position while many others that a position of developer. For
example, we are trying to find the major directions of our
work, i.e. it is a strategic approach that does not care
about details. Moreover, it is a dangerous matter if we
agree on some details now because it is more likely than not
these details will require revisions.
I hate a method of constant refining instead of taking a
good thinking up-from and defining the goal, objectives, and
answers to WHAT, WHY, WHOI, WHEN WHERE. HOW it could be
implemented will be addressed later when we find the
subjects and constraints. As a part of this approach, we
will be able to build proper vocabulary, as needed, but it
will be about the major rather than secondary things first.
I counr on the rule 80/20 in this case.
As of the Template proposed by Anil, I looked at it (as an
architect). It is a very well documented USER-CASE, i.e.
the description of what one does with something known (via
features of interfaces). IMO, it is not we need at this
stage (but when we define what is the solution for the
Authorisation for Clouds, we will need a set of use-cases to
demonstrate how to use this solution).
For now, we need BUSINESS CASES, i.e. a set of stories that
define business situations where the task
of Authorisation for Clouds should be resolved.
Yes, tasks, not answers or solution. If I take the Anil's
template, here is how I validate it for the Business-Case.
If the feedback to my proposal (see above) of the
Business-Case Template is approaved by the TC, I am ready to
re-write the set of business cases I submitted in the agreed
format.
Looking for your feedback,
- Michael Poulin
----- Original Message -----
From: Anil Saldhana
Sent: 02/12/13 09:34 PM
To: cloudauthz@lists.oasis-open.org
Subject: [cloudauthz] Use
Case Template for CloudAuthZ
|