Re: [ubl-ndrsc] Proposed Modification to [ELN4] - ASBIE Naming

[Tim McGrath <tmcgrath@portcomm.com.au>]

the point i was trying to make in my earlier email was that 
InvoiceLegalTotal is a legitimate re-use of the LegalTotal (in a 
specific context).  we will never want to reuse InvoiceLegalTotal in any 
other place because it describes a unique association.  The qualifiers 
should not be part the type.  The type of an ASBIE is always the type of 
the ABIE being associated with.
this rule reads like a reverse engineering of the schemas rather than a 
logical interpretation of the principles behind it.

PS

shouldn't
<xsd:element name="InvoiceLegalTotal" type="cat:LegalTotal"/>
be

<xsd:element name="InvoiceLegalTotal" type="cat:LegalTotalType"/>


Grimley Michael J NPRI wrote:

>[ELN4] A UBL global element name based on an ccts:ASBIE MUST be the
>ccts:ASBIE dictionary entry name property term and qualifiers; and the
>object class term and qualifiers of its associated ccts:ABIE. All
>ccts:DictionaryEntryName separators MUST be removed.
>
><New>If the omission of the ccts:ASBIE dictionary entry name object class
>term results in a name collision then the ccts:ASBIE dictionary entry
>name object class term MUST be added to the beginning of the element name.</New>
>
>Redundant words in the ccts:ASBIE property term or qualifiers and the
>associated ccts:ABIE object class term or qualifiers MUST be dropped <New>unless
>the result produces a name collision</New>.
>
>
>
>EXAMPLES:
>====================================
>With object class:
>
><xsd:element ref="InvoiceLegalTotal">
>  <xsd:annotation>
>    <xsd:documentation>
>      <ccts:Component>
>        <ccts:CategoryCode>ASBIE</ccts:CategoryCode>
>        <ccts:DictionaryEntryName>Invoice. Legal Total</ccts:DictionaryEntryName>
>        <ccts:Definition>Associates the invoice with a set of totals...</ccts:Definition>
>        <ccts:ObjectClass>Invoice</ccts:ObjectClass>
>        <ccts:PropertyTerm>LegalTotal</ccts:PropertyTerm>
>        <ccts:RepresentationTerm>LegalTotal</ccts:RepresentationTerm>
>        <ccts:DataType>LegalTotal.Type</ccts:DataType>
>        <ccts:AssociatedObjectClass>LegalTotal</ccts:AssociatedObjectClass>
>      </ccts:Component>
>    </xsd:documentation>
>  </xsd:annotation>
></xsd:element>
>
>Because there is already a Global Element named 'LegalTotal' in the Reusable schema, and we add no additional qualifiers, we will have a name collision if we don't include the Object Class. Therefore, ASBIE Global Element Name becomes 'InvoiceLegalTotal'. (Yes, Gunther, this is a direct result of our Global Element decision.):
>
><xsd:element name="InvoiceLegalTotal" type="cat:LegalTotal"/>
>
>====================================
>Without object class:
>
><xsd:element ref="AdditionalDocumentReference" minOccurs="0" maxOccurs="unbounded">
>  <xsd:annotation>
>    <xsd:documentation>
>      <ccts:Component>
>        <ccts:CategoryCode>ASBIE</ccts:CategoryCode>
>        <ccts:DictionaryEntryName>Invoice. Additional_  Document Reference. Document Reference</ccts:DictionaryEntryName>
>        <ccts:Definition>Provides other means of identifying an Invoice </ccts:Definition>
>        <ccts:ObjectClass>Invoice</ccts:ObjectClass>
>        <ccts:QualifierPropertyTerm>Additional</ccts:QualifierPropertyTerm>
>        <ccts:PropertyTerm>DocumentReference</ccts:PropertyTerm>
>        <ccts:RepresentationTerm>DocumentReference</ccts:RepresentationTerm>
>        <ccts:DataType>DocumentReference.Type</ccts:DataType>
>        <ccts:AssociatedObjectClass>DocumentReference</ccts:AssociatedObjectClass>
>      </ccts:Component>
>    </xsd:documentation>
>  </xsd:annotation>
></xsd:element>
>
>Because we have the qualifier 'Additional', we have no need to include the Object Class in order to prevent name collision with global 'DocumentReference' in Reusable:
>
><xsd:element name="AdditionalDocumentReference" type="cat:DocumentReferenceType"/>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>To unsubscribe from this mailing list (and be removed from the roster of the OASIS TC), go to http://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/ubl-ndrsc/members/leave_workgroup.php.
>
>  
>

-- 
regards
tim mcgrath
phone: +618 93352228  
postal: po box 1289   fremantle    western australia 6160