RE: [cgmo-webcgm] features missing 2-pass criteria

["Ulrich Laesche" <ulrich@cgmtech.de>]

I have downloaded the latest matrix from the CGMOpen ftp site and inserted
our latest test results / status.  To not potentially mix up different
versions of the file I send it by mail for further processing.

Regards
Ulrich

P.S.: I will only be able to join the telco for 15 min today but will call
in.


-----Original Message-----
From: Lofton Henderson [mailto:lofton@rockynet.com] 
Sent: Dienstag, 10. November 2009 17:25
To: cgmo-webcgm@lists.oasis-open.org
Cc: David Cruikshank
Subject: [cgmo-webcgm] features missing 2-pass criteria

I'm looking at the most recent implementation matrix [1] and I have a
concern:
[1] ftp://ftp.cgmlarson.com/new21-matrix-master.html

As expected, these at-risk features will probably get dropped:
1.)  ACI Line Type Continuation
2.)  ACI Edge Type Continuation
3.)  XCF access to transform stuff.

However, we also are missing 2-pass on these features!!!
4.) ACI Line & Edge Type Definition	
5.) ACI Hatch Style Definition

We also put those "at risk".

Do we really intend to abandon both of those?!  IIRC, they were 
top-priority items for Boeing.

The matrix shows that Ulrich was going to implement at least the LETD.
Ulrich?

Neither of these is difficult, if you stick to basics as the test does.

Thoughts?

-Lofton.


---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe from this mail list, you must leave the OASIS TC that
generates this mail.  Follow this link to all your TCs in OASIS at:
https://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/portal/my_workgroups.php

Title: WebCGM 2.1 new-tests Implementation Matrix

WebCGM 2.1 New-test Implementation Matrix
19 October 2009

Latest version:

http://.../new21-matrix.html

This version:

http://.../new21matrix-2009mmdd.html

Previous version:

http://.../new21matrix-2009mmdd.html

Introduction

This document describes the results of WebCGM 2.1 implementations tested against the module of new 2.1 tests of the WebCGM 2.1 Test Suite.

Information about the implementations and a legend explaining the table are found after the table.

new2.1 tests — new tests of features new to WebCGM 2.1

Test Name	IsoView	VizEx	SDI Reader	MetaWeb	Comments
aciDefaultFont (chgd 9/2)	Fail**	Pass	Fail**	Pass	cgm fixed(9/2)
aciSimpleFontSubsitution (chgd 9/2)	Fail**	Pass	Fail**	Pass	cgm fixed(9/2)
aciForceSubstitution (chgd 9/2)	Fail**	Pass	Fail**	Pass	cgm fixed(9/2)
aciFontNormalization (chgd 9/2)	Fail**	Pass	Fail**	Pass	cgm fixed(9/2)
aciGenericFonts (chgd 9/2)	Fail**	Pass	Fail**	Pass	cgm fixed(9/2)
aciMapListOrder (chgd 9/2)	Fail**	Pass	Fail**	Pass	cgm fixed(9/2)
aciLineAttr (chgd 9/2)	Fail**	Pass	Partial	Partial	See note sdi1
aciEdgeAttr (chgd 9/2)	Fail**	Pass	Partial	Partial	See note sdi2
aciMitreLimit (chgd 9/2)	Fail**	Pass	Pass	Fail	png line width fixed(9/2)
aciRestrictedTextType (chgd 9/2)	Fail**	Pass	Pass	Pass	cgm, png fixed(9/2)
aciLineEdgeTypeDef (chgd 9/2)	Fail**	Pass	Fail(2010)**	Pass	html fixed(9/2)
aciHatchStyleDef (chgd 9/2)	Fail**	Pass	Fail(2010)**	Fail	cgm, png fixed(9/2)
setGetBGColor	Partial(-)	Pass	Pass	Pass	n/c
setGetTextStyles (8/26 chgd)	Fail**	Pass	Pass	Pass	FC fixed test (8/26)
setGetIntensity	Fail	Partial(11/1)	Pass	Fail	n/c
setGetLineStyles2.0 (8/31 chgd)	Fail**	Pass	Pass	Partial	FC chgd cgm,png(8/31)
setGetFillStyles2.0 (8/31 chgd)	Fail**	Pass	Pass	Partial	FC chgd cgm,png(8/31)
setGetStrokeType (8/31 chgd)	Fail**	Pass	Pass	Fail	FC chgd cgm,png(8/31)
setGetStrokeOffset	Fail	Pass	Pass	Fail	n/c
setGetInteriorStyle	Fail	Pass	Pass	Fail	n/c
setGetHatchIndex (9/2 chgd)	Fail**	Pass	Pass	Fail	FC chgd cgm,png(9/2)
setGetPatternIndex	Fail	Pass	Pass	Fail	n/c
setGetEdgeVisibility (9/2 chgd)	Fail**	Pass	Pass	Pass	FC chgd cgm,png(9/2)
setGetFillOffset2 (new I.I. 9/2)	unk**	Pass	Pass	Fail	FC IntrpInt version (9/2)
getObjectExtent (9/4 chgd)	Fail**	Pass	Pass	Pass	SG fixed lwsm(9/4)
getObjectExtentTransformed (9/4 chgd)	Fail**	Pass	Pass	Pass	SG to fix lwsm(9/4)
setView001	Pass	Pass	Pass	Pass	n/c
setView002	Pass	Pass	Fail(11/1)	Pass	n/c
scaleAPS	Fail	Pass	Partial(10/15)	Pass	n/c
rotateAPS	Fail	Pass	Partial(10/15)	Pass	n/c
translateAPS	Fail	Pass	Partial(10/15)	Pass	n/c
transformAPS	Fail	Pass	Partial(10/15)	Pass	n/c
rotateAnimation (chgd 10/19)	Fail	Pass**	Pass**	Partial	n/c
translateAnimation	Fail	Pass	Pass	Pass	n/c
transformAnimation	Fail	Pass	Pass	Pass	n/c
lineAnimation	Fail	Pass	Pass	Fail	n/c
subString	Fail	Fail(-)	Pass	Pass	n/c
zCompress	Pass	Pass	Pass	Pass	n/c
setRedraw001	Pass	Pass	Pass	Pass	n/c
setRedraw002	Fail	Pass	Fail(11/1)	Pass	UL fixed HTML(9/30)
spXCF	unk**	Pass	Pass	Fail
transformXCF	unk**	Fail(no)**	Pass	Fail

Note: ** means test has changed, implementation retest required.

static2.0 tests — new tests of static features that existed in 2.0

Test Name	IsoView	VizEx	SDI Reader	MetaWeb	Comments
lineOffset	Fail	Pass	Pass	Fail	--
transCellColor	Fail	Pass	Pass	Fail	--
alphaEscape	Fail	Pass	Pass	Fail	--

Comments (from above tables)

• sdi1 -- implementation passes all aspects and subtests of the test except the Line Type Continuation.
• sdi2 -- implementation passes all aspects and subtests of the test except the Edge Type Continuation.

Implementations Tested

The following table lists the Viewer implementations that are covered by the test results.

Company	Name**	Product	Version	Platform
PTC	IsoView	Arbortext IsoView	8.0 beta	Windows XP
Larson Software Technology	VizEx	VizEx Web	10.0	Windows XP
System Development Inc	SDI Reader	SDI Reader	1.06	Windows XP
CGM Technology Services	MetaWeb	MetaWeb	3.2	Windows XP

** Nickname used for the viewer in the tables (to distinguish multiple viewers from a Company).

Legend

Type	Description
Pass	Implementation passes test
Fail(date)	Implementation does not pass test. (Committed pass date)***
Partial(date)	Implementation passes part of the test, but not enough to give a full pass. (Committed pass date.)***
Unknown	The implementation behavior is unknown or indeterminate for the test.
Inactive	An implementation is planned, but not yet advanced enough for testing.

*** "(indef)" or "(-)" means that vendor cannot estimate or commit, when it will pass. "No" means no present plans to implement.