Re: [ebxml-cppa] CPPA version 1.04

[Arvola Chan <arvola@tibco.com>]

Tony:

 

I just notice that the CPP and CPA samples included in the 1.04 package don't correspond to my local copies (but to the previous version of these files). I must have failed to send you the updated files last week.

 

The changes I plan to contribute to the 1.05 draft are very limited. They include:

• Alignment of naming of attributes under BusinessProcessCharacteristics with the BPSS spec as follows:
• authenticated -> isAuthenticated
• confidentiality -> isConfidential
• nonRepudiationOfOrigin -> isNonRepudiationRequired
• nonRepudiationOfReceipt -> isNonRepudiationReceiptRequired
• secureTransport -> isSecureTransportRequired
• authorized -> isAuthorizationRequired
• Minor RFC 2119 keyword changes to Appendix D and Appendix G.
• Updated schema
• Updated CPP examples
• Updated CPA example

I will make my changes on top of the 1.04 draft (having first accepted all previous changes). I plan to send you my changes by the end of today, along with a powerpoint file summarizing all major changes since the 1.0 version.

 

Regards,

-Arvola

-----Original Message-----
From: Tony Weida <rweida@hotmail.com>
To: CPPA <ebxml-cppa@lists.oasis-open.org>
Date: Monday, January 21, 2002 5:56 AM
Subject: [ebxml-cppa] CPPA version 1.04

 CPPA version 1.04 is attached.  The zip file includes the specification, the XSD, an example CPA, and example CPPs.  Feedback on this version of the specification will be accepted through Tuesday, January 22, following the schedule published on January 3. 

 

Changes from Arvola include:

1. Clarify that ReceiptAcknowledgment, AcceptanceAcknowledgment, and Exception are the values for the action attribute that should be used for business signals.
2. Move syncReplyMode attribute from BusinessProcessCharacteristics to MessagingCharacteristics.
3. Clarify meaning of RetryInterval.
4. Clarify meaning of PersistDuration.
5. Added xlink:role attribute to SimplePart to be consistent with Reference element in message header.
6. Clarify that cpaid attribute in CollaborationProtocolAgreement element MUST be used as CPAId in ebXML Message Header.
7. Clarify that the max cardinality for ds:Signature should be 3.
8. Update synchronous reply mode examples in the sample CPPs and CPA by introducing a second ServiceBinding.
9. Mention use of wildcard elements for extensibility purposes in Appendix D.
10. Added comments about the requirement for explicit declaration of the xml namespace by some parsers in draft-cpp-cpa-011.xsd.
11. Add normative appendix summarizing correspondence between Messaging parameters and CPP/A elements and attributes as Appendix G.

Peter Ogden suplied a non-normative note on avoiding ID attribute clashes for the section entitled ID Attribute Duplication.

 

My own changes include:

• Added a statement on the capitalization of RFC 2119 and other keywords; in an effort to avoid confusion abut intended or unintended use of capitalization, all occurrances of RFC 2119 keywords not in all capital letters were either converted to all caps or replaced with an equivalent word or phrase in lower case letters (e.g., needed in place of required).  Exceptions were made for XML markup and official copyright statements.
• Explicitly identified and discussed the ds:URI attribute, ds:DigestMethod element and ds:DigestValue element of ds:Reference (Issue 149)
• Removed non-normative text on use of CPA with intermediaries  from the section on Design Objectives (Issue 196)
• Removed references to ebXML glossary, added a placeholder appendix for an internal glossary, and updated references accordingly (towards Issue 72) 
• Minor editorial changes

Cheers,

Tony Weida