Re: revised-ebMS V1.01 Editorial changes

[iwasa <iwasa@fs.fujitsu.com>]

Hi Colleen,

Thanks for the update. I've checked the revised
specification. And it seems to be fine.

Best Regards,
Iwasa

----- Original Message -----
From: "Colleen Evans" <cevans@sonicsoftware.com>
To: "iwasa" <iwasa@fs.fujitsu.com>; "ebXML Msg"
<ebxml-msg@lists.oasis-open.org>
Sent: Monday, October 01, 2001 12:50 PM
Subject: Re: revised-ebMS V1.01 Editorial changes


> Hi Iwasa,
> I have incorporated your suggested text (along with the clarification
> provided by Shimamura in the referenced archived email) in the V1.02
version
> distributed to the list this afternoon. See section 7.4.8 on page 33, line
> numbers 1265 through 1280.  I hope it accurately reflects the use of
> SequenceNumber.
>
> Best regards,
> Colleen
>
> iwasa wrote:
>
> >
> > I have some feedback to the updated spec as follows:
> >
> > [Issue63, 64]
> > As I made comments on the teleconference,
> > the proposed sentence doesn't solve the problem. Because
> > it doesn't say when SequenceNumber is required.
> >
> > My proposed sentence for Line#1070-1074 is:
> > --------------------------------------------
> > The SequenceNumber element MUST appear
> > when deliverySemantics has a value of
> > OnceAndOnlyOnce and messageOrderSemantics
> > has a value of Guaranteed. Otherwise, SequenceNumber
> > MAY NOT appear. If deliverySemantics doesn't
> > have a value of OnceAndOnlyOnce, SequenceNumber
> > MUST NOT appear. If this criterion is not met,
> > an error MUST be reported to the From Party MSH with
> > an errorCode of Inconsistent and a severity of Error.
> > -------------------------------------------
> >
> > This explanation is based on the original sentence,
> > and made clarification as we concluded.
> >
> > The point here is:
> >   - SequenceNumber MUST appear when:
> >             deliverySemantics="OnceAndOnlyOnce" and
> >             messageOrderSemantics="Guaranteed"
> >   - Otherwise it is NOT REQUIRED. (And spec doesn't
> >      preclude to put sequenceNumber, when
> >      deliverySemantics="OnceAndOnlyOnce")
> >   - SequenceNumber MUST NOT appear when
> >      deliverySemantincs="BestEffort"
> >
> > This was discussed already, and came to a conclusion.
> > See :
> >  <http://lists.ebxml.org/archives/ebxml-transport/200103/msg00104.html>.
> >
> > Iwasa
> >
> > ----- Original Message -----
> > From: "Colleen Evans" <cevans@sonicsoftware.com>
> > To: "ebXML Msg" <ebxml-msg@lists.oasis-open.org>
> > Sent: Monday, September 24, 2001 3:34 PM
> > Subject: revised-ebMS V1.01 Editorial changes
> >
> > > Based on today's TC call, there are a few changes required
> > > to the draft version I sent out earlier (ebMS V1.01 draft 21
> > > Sep 2001).  The attached spec (ebMS V1.01 draft 24 Sep 2001)
> > > includes those modifications. The accompanying issues list
> > > documents what evolved on today's call, resulting in the
> > > changes to the draft spec.  Effected issues are highlighted.
> > >
> > > After Thursday's deadline for comment (9/27), I will accept
> > > changes in the document, and add the T1 modifications from
> > > Ralph.  Then we can start the whole process over again next
> > > week at the f2f with the remaining issues.
> > >
> > > Colleen
> > >
> > >
>
> --
> Colleen Evans
> Principal Product Manager
> Sonic Software Corporation
> phone:  720 480-3919 or 303 791-3090
> email:  cevans@sonicsoftware.com
> website:  http://www.sonicsoftware.com
>
>