Re: [ebxml-msg] Minutes October 22

[iwasa <iwasa@fs.fujitsu.com>]

Ian,

My name is missing in the list.
Thanks,

Iwasa
Fujitsu

----- Original Message -----
From: <ian.c.jones@bt.com>
To: <ebxml-msg@lists.oasis-open.org>
Sent: Thursday, October 25, 2001 1:53 AM
Subject: [ebxml-msg] Minutes October 22


> Team,
>
> the minutes of our conference call on Monday October 22 in word
> format can be read from :
>
http://www.oasis-open.org/committees/ebxml-msg/minutes/TeleConference_10_22_
> 2001.doc
> (Watch for the underscores if the URL wraps or just go to the OASIS web
> site.)
>
> Please tell me if I missed anyone from the roll call as it affects
> YOUR voting status and any errors.
>
> Apologies for the delay I was hoping to be able to add the Face to
> face Details and put them on the web site before sending them out.
>
> Below is an unformatted text version.
>
> Conference Call 10/22/01 Minutes
>
> Hosted by Sonic Software (Colleen Evans)
>
> David Burdett
> Doug Bunting
> Arvola Chan
> Colleen Evans
> Chris Ferris
> David Fischer
> Ian Jones
> Brad Lund
> Bruce Pedretti
> David Smiley
> Jeff Turpin
> Dan Weinreb
> Pete Wenzel
> Prasad Yendluri
>
> Apologies
> Bob Miller
>
>
> Agenda Items
> 1. Roll Call - see above
>
> 2. Unanimous vote of those present to accept reformatted specification
> (1.05) as the basis for all work to produce version 1.1
>
> 3. David Burdett, Chris Ferris and David Fischer who produced this
> restructured version and hence have the best understanding of the impact
of
> any changes in this version based on the current issue list believe that
the
> end date is still achievable.
> The issue of conformance levels and optimality was discussed as part of
the
> discussion and the current understanding is that the IIC TC will be
> producing a set of "profiles" defining the required functionality to meet
> defined conformance conditions.  This will be in separate document(s) and
> not part of the messagae service specification.
>
> 4. Outstanding Issues List as published by Arvola Chan October 10.
> Sync Reply
> Issue 9 - CPPA team will be asked to include a mshSignalsOnly sync reply
> mode.
> Issue 10 - Decision sync replay MAY be used with out reliable messaging -
> clarification to specification text.
> Issue 51 - Clarification of QualityOfServiceInfo - ReliableMessagingMethod
> to be removed.
> Issue 58 - SyncyReply in both header and Via elements. - This lead to a
> lengthy discussion the highlighted a probably underlying issue that
> "SyncReply" was performing 2 different function depending on its location
> and that one probably need a different name and definition.  This will
> require working through in conjunction with the CPPA TC.  It also
> highlighted the issue of who will any conflict between the 2 be resolved
> especially if one is in the CPPA and the other is in the message.  This in
> turn started the discussion in terms of priority and overrides which MUST
be
> resolved in the specification, as it was an outstanding issue from version
> 1.0 of the specifications.
>
> Reliable Messaging Parameters
> Issue 20 - Relationship of CPPA and Message header values - This was
> continued from the previous discussion.  It was agreed that the names and
> definitions of element and attributes must be consistent across both
> specifications that currently they are not. After lengthy discussion this
> issue was agreed to be too large to address on this call and will require
> thorough resolution at the next Face to Face meeting.  Dan volunteered to
> have a look at which values relating to reliable messaging were defined in
> the header and or the CPPA to give as a start at the meeting.
>
> 5. For next weeks call it was agreed that we would tackle some of the
> smaller issues to allow the editor to apply as many minor changes as
> possible before the face to face.
>
> 6. Conference call Schedule - all calls Monday 10:00 Pacific/1:00
> Eastern
> October 29 - Hosted by Dale Moberg - Cyclone
> November 5 - Hosted by David Smiley - Mercator - Voting
> .
> 7. Next face to Face - Chris Ferris and David Burdett have secured
> facilities in Burlington, Ma, and Pleasanton Ca, and a video conference
link
> for most of the meeting. They will be posting full details soon.
>
> Next call October 29 @ 10:00 Pacific, 1:00 Eastern.
>
>
> Ian Jones
> Chair OASIS ebXML Messaging Services TC
>
> Tel:  +44 (0)29 2072 4063
> Fax: +44 (0)29 2072 4137
> Email: ian.c.jones@bt.com
>
>
> ----------------------------------------------------------------
> To subscribe or unsubscribe from this elist use the subscription
> manager: <http://lists.oasis-open.org/ob/adm.pl>