[Date Prev] | [Thread Prev] | [Thread Next] | [Date Next] -- [Date Index] | [Thread Index] | [List Home]
Subject: Re: [emergency] EDXL Schema and Test message
That's great, David... thanks! A few quick notes on first inspection: * In the enumeration of <messageType> I assume the intended spelling is "Response". (Presumably just typo.) * Likewise, I think the spellings of the element names should be "contentObject", "confidentiality" and "llConfidentiality". (For discussion: might we want to change that last one to "lowestConfidentiality" just for readability?) * For the default namespace I'd suggest we substitute one in the OASIS style, like "urn:oasis:names:tc:emergency:edxl:distribution_1.0". (Among other things, using this URN form might help alleviate any confusion between the namespace value and the schema location.) * Regarding the structure of <contentObject>: I think our intent, eventually, was to rename the CAP <resource> element to <contentObject> and reuse this extended structure. So might it work better if the choice were between the explicit, separately-namespaced XML (as in this draft, but with the name lower-cased) and the current content of <resource> but without the additional wrapper elements? (The future effect on CAP would be to allow the in-lining of other XML content without having to uuencode it, which strikes me as a good thing.) * I'm not quite clear on your comment "We need to develop pattern for URN"... it appears to be in the context of the <valueListUrn> element. Is an additional restriction needed beyond requiring that it be a valid URN? * Regarding your comments on <targetArea>... I don't think we intended to support separate targetings for individual <messageElement>s. The idea, I think, was that the whole message has a common targeting, which might be the union of multiple <targetArea>s. So there really wouldn't be any need for a reference ID on <targetArea>s. Again, thanks for all your great input at the meeting and for taking the first cut at the schema. (And I'm throwing the full weight of my influence with DTRA behind getting you your funding. ;-) ) - Art
[Date Prev] | [Thread Prev] | [Thread Next] | [Date Next] -- [Date Index] | [Thread Index] | [List Home]