[Date Prev] | [Thread Prev] | [Thread Next] | [Date Next] -- [Date Index] | [Thread Index] | [List Home]
Subject: Re: [kmip] Concerns with Encrypt, Decrypt, Sign and Verify
Bob, Kiran, and others ... On the in-scope or out-of-scope item discussion and the note that most of the focus for KMIP 1.2 is arguably outside the current charter we resolved in the face to face that we would head down the re-charter path removing all the out-of-scope items from the current charter for KMIP 1.2 but only commence that process after the OASIS organisation-wide vote on the KMIP 1.1 specification was complete and that we would work on each of the items in parallel with that process and the proposing companies would explicitly re-contribute them (or generally re-contribute all past contributions) prior to reaching a KMIP 1.2 specification draft. We have in the past worked on items noted as out-of-scope and proposals have been presented (on quite a few of the topics) and there has been no issues raised to date that working on those items is acceptable - provided that we do not place any out-of-scope item in a committee draft specification - i.e. only work products. See the brief note in the f2f day3 minutes on the topic. It is one of the challenges we face in the face to face meetings - how to have the details of the discussions more accessible to those who are not present physically at the meetings. Remote participation as many have noted is difficult. The minutes attempt to capture the key details - but the discussions are not always able to be noted with all the nuances. I'll respond on the scope of the cryptographic services proposal separately. Thanks, Tim.