Re: [regrep] A different perspective on OASIS ebXML v3 enhancementproposals.. .

[Nikola <nikola.stojanovic@acm.org>]

<Joel>

 I see a very big not-invented-here attitude.

...

Before you commit to reinventing, ..

</Joel>

 

<Matt>
Your points are valid (although I may disagree on some details), but this work (your [1-3]) was started before UDDI was swallowed into OASIS.

</Matt>

 

In http://lists.ebxml.org/archives/ebxml-regrep/200105/msg00018.html there is "The DRAFT Revised Charter for the OASIS ebXML Registry and Repository Technical Committee"

 

<snip>

Additionally, as part of its specification development work, this TC explores and promotes various emerging models for distributed and cooperating registries.

</snip>

 

According to http://lists.ebxml.org/archives/ebxml-regrep/200005/msg00010.html

 

<Scott>

We are promoting and requiring a network of registries and repositories as that is the only architecture that will scale over the Internet.
</Scott>

 

one can conclude that ebXML Registry TC has been working on some of these items as early as May 2000.

 

Nikola