RE: comments: draft-sstc-saml-metadata-ext-query-02

["Scott Cantor" <cantor.2@osu.edu>]

> [line 68] It's misleading to call this "SAML V2.0 metadata query
> extension" since the profile applies to both V1.1 and V2.0 query
> requesters.

I've retitled it, which is also more consistent with the metadata profile
draft's title (just starts with Metadata alone).

> > [line 116, 138, 160] These lines refer to the SAML V1.x Metadata
> > Profile, which does not apply, however, since any type derived from
> > md:RoleDescriptorType is undefined. Thus these types are not profiled
> > for use with SAML 1.x metadata.  This is a serious omission.
> 
> After reading the latest version of the SAML V1.x Metadata Profile, I
> don't see how this problem has been fixed.

I don't see any issues with the current draft documents, and haven't changed
any of the related text for the new drafts. You'll have to identify what you
think is wrong. The RoleDescriptor exclusion has been removed from the
underlying profile, and I saw no other issues of concern.

The remaining issues are addressed in the forthcoming draft.

-- Scott