Re: [ubl-dev] Mapping from Genericode <Identification> tags to UBL Code attributes?

[Steve Capell <steve.capell@gmail.com>]

My personal view (which will no doubt trigger some objections) that they are all redundant except a schemeURI which uniquely tells you everything you need about the code list issuer, list id, version, etc...


Steven Capell
Mob: 0410 437854

> On 23 May 2018, at 8:00 pm, David Goodenough <david.goodenough@broadwellmanor.co.uk> wrote:
> 
> Is there a document anywhere that maps the items in the Genericode <Identification> section to the UBL Code attributes.
>  
> The UBL code attributes being:-
>  
> ListId,ListAgencyId,ListAgencyName,ListName,ListVersionId,Name,LanguageId,ListURI,ListSchemaURI
>  
> and the Genericode tags being:-
>  
> ShortName, LongName (two form, second being ListId), Version, CanonicalUri, CanonicalVersionURI, LocationUri, AlternativeFormatLocationUrl, Agency (LongName and Identifier).
>  
> My assumption would be:-
>  
> UBL	Genericode
> ===	=======
> ListId LongName/@Identifier="listID"
> ListAgencyId Agency/Identifier
> ListAgencyName	Agency/LongName
> ListName	LongName (not listId version)
> ListVersionId	?? Does not seem to be encoded in Genericode
> Name	ShortName
> LanguageId	?? I guess this come from one of the two xml:lang attributes,	?? what if they are different
> ListURI	LocationUri
> ListSchemaURI	?? Is this the gc:CodeList/@xmlns:gc value ??
>  
> Was a formal mapping done when UBL moved to using Genericode?
>  
> Also putting all of these values into every code in a UBL document seems rather redundant, is it considered valid to put just the ListId (possibly also the AgencyID to ensure uniqueness) in the subsequent instances of the same code list?
>  
> David