Re: [ws-rx] Issue i042 proposal

[Anish Karmarkar <Anish.Karmarkar@oracle.com>]

I would like to support this motion with but with an important 
caveat/friendly amendment:

Given the importance of the version of WS-Addressing for interop, in 
deferring this issue I would like to record the sense of the TC (if
TC agrees to do so) that for the Implementation SC and interop
events/efforts, the TC will be cognizant of the changes that have been
made to the WS-Addressing spec by the WS-Addressing WG. For example,
Reference Properties have been removed, the syntactic structure of an
EPR has changed, the default Action value for faults, default Action
algorithm for WSDL, defaulting of wsa:To has changed. Wherever possible
the interop effort will adopt the recent changes that have been made to
WS-Addressing.

Thx.

-Anish
--

Marc Goodner wrote:
> Similar to how we have deferred deciding on updating references to WSS 
> 1.1 until it is an OASIS Standard we should follow the same practice 
> with WS-A. We expect broader support for the REC version of WS-A than 
> any interim drafts. For WS-A this is particularly important as TC 
> members may want to implement interim CDs of WS-RM but may only have 
> support for the contributed version of WS-A in their stack and no plans 
> for supporting interim drafts of WS-A.  
> 
>  
> 
> Motion: Defer updating references to WS-A at this time. We should reopen 
> this issue after WS-A progresses to Proposed Recommendation with the 
> intention of updating the reference when WS-A reaches REC status.
> 
>  
>