Re: [wss] Status of 1.1 submission

[ronald monzillo <Ronald.Monzillo@Sun.COM>]

Chris and Kelvin,

First of all, thanks for editing the docs.

It looks like the pdf that was produced for the stp has change bars
(which should be removed before submission).

If another round of editing is in order, I would prefer to work on this
today, as I have other commitments tomorrow.

please let me know if you would like my help,

Ron

PS: section 2.2 of the stp was intended to sustain the examples without
namespace declarations. That said, if namespace declarations must be
included in the examples, and if we have another reason or opportunity
to edit the profile, I think the profile should be changed to employ the
namespace declaration shorthand used in the other documents (e.g.
xmlns:S12="...").


Chris Kaler wrote On 11/16/05 02:28,:
> 
> 
> Members of the TC,
>  
> The new submission guidelines require that all XML used in examples be
> well formed and that submitters certify they have checked it.  As part
> of the preparations to submit our 1.1 documents, we have gone through
> every sample in all seven documents and have unfortunately found several
> places where the XML had some type of syntax error (e.g. missing “/” or
> missing closing element, etc).  We have produced a set of documents that
> contain the edits required to fix these errors, but we are not sure
> exactly how to proceed.  We have contacted the OASIS staff for advice
> and asked for an exemption to the “no edit” rule so that we can fix the
> XML to be well-formed, but have not heard back yet.  We’ll let you know
> as soon as we hear a ruling.  We have submitted the paperwork just in
> case we can proceed if allowed.  
>  
> We have uploaded the edited drafts into the “Specifications” folder (to
> keep them separate) in case people want to take a look at them.  Below
> is a list of the XML errors that are fixed in the uploaded copies.
> 
>  
> 
> Stay tuned…
> 
>  
> 
> Kelvin and Chris
> 
>  
> 
> 
> CORE
> Line 1923 mismatched <SecurityTokenReference> (missing closing element)
> 
> Kerberos
> Example on page 10 does not have an xmlns:wsu entry
> Example on page 11 does not have an xmlns:wsu entry
> Line 252 there is a bogus quote (") before the attribute declaration
> 
> X.509
> Line 391 ending tag is typo'd should be </ds:X509SerialNumber>
> Line 434 ending tag is typo'd should be </ds:X509SerialNumber>
> 
> SAML
> Line 193 The element has no closing ">"
> Line 193 There is no namespcae declaration for xmlns:saml
> Line 197 The element has no closing ">"
> Line 207 There is no xmlns:ds
> Line 216 The element has no closing ">"
> Line 242 There is no closing ">"
> Line 242 There is no xmlns:saml2 declaration
> Line 252 There is no xmlns:xsi declaration
> Line 258 There is no xmlns:ds declaration
> Line 302 There is no xmlns:s12 declaration
> Line 302 There is no xmlns:wsse declaration
> Line 302 There is no xmlns:saml declaration
> Line 311 There is no closing ">"
> Line 421 There is no xmlns:S12 declaration
> Line 421 There is no xmlns:wsse declaration
> Line 421 There is no xmlns:saml declaration
> Line 421 There is no xmlns:wsse11 declaration
> Line 421 There is no xmlns:wsu declaration
> Line 429 There is no closing ">"
> Line 713 There is no xmlns:S12 declaration
> Line 713 There is no xmlns:wsse declaration
> Line 713 There is no xmlns:ds declaration
> Line 713 There is no xmlns:saml declaration
> Line 713 There is no xmlns:wsu declaration
> Line 726 <saml:Conditions> has no matching end tag
> Line 802 There is no xmlns:S12 declaration
> Line 802 There is no xmlns:wsse declaration
> Line 802 There is no xmlns:wsse11 declaration
> Line 802 There is no xmlns:ds declaration
> Line 802 There is no xmlns:saml2 declaration
> Line 802 There is no xmlns:wsu declaration
> Line 802 There is no xmlns:xsi declaration
> Line 808 The "..." needs to be deleted
> Line 811 The "...>" needs to be replaced by ">"
> Line 904 There is no xmlns:S12 declaration
> Line 904 There is no xmlns:wsse declaration
> Line 904 There is no xmlns:wsse11 declaration
> Line 904 There is no xmlns:ds declaration
> Line 904 There is no xmlns:saml declaration
> Line 904 There is no xmlns:wsu declaration
> Line 904 There is no xmlns:xsi declaration
> Line 918 The tag <saml:Conditions> has no matching end tag
> Line 938 The tag <saml:Attribute is missing the closing ">"
> Line 1012 There is no xmlns:S12 declaration
> Line 1012 There is no xmlns:wsse declaration
> Line 1012 There is no xmlns:wsse11 declaration
> Line 1012 There is no xmlns:ds declaration
> Line 1012 There is no xmlns:saml2 declaration
> Line 1012 There is no xmlns:wsu declaration
> Line 1012 There is no xmlns:xsi declaration
> Line 938 The tag <saml:Assertion needs to be reformulated as for line 808
> 
> REL
> Line 188 There is no xmlns:ds declaration
> Line 219 The xmlns:wsu declaration is in the wrong place. Needs to be
> promoted to the envelope element
> Line 236 <reference> is missing the ds: prefix
> Line 237 <Transforms> is missing the ds: prefix
> Line 264 There is no xmlns:ds declaration
> Line 383 there is an erroneous "@" before wsu:Id
> Line 435 There is no xmlns:ds declaration
> Line 495 Same problem with missing xmlns declarations but we might let
> this go as it is a fragment, although sx really should be defined
> Line 518 Same problem with missing xmlns declarations but we might let
> this go as it is a fragment, although sx really should be defined
> 
> SWA
> Line 673 There is no xmlns:wsu declaration
> Line 677 xmlns:ds is typo'd as xmls:ds
> Line 697 </X509SerialNumber> is missing the ds: prefix
> Line 707 </EncryptedKey> is missing the xenc: prefix
> Line 716 Missing double quote on attribute cid:bar";
> Line 727 xenc:EncryptedData missing the closing ">"
> 
>  
> 

--