Perhaps we should bring this item for discussion on tomorrow's call. I
could then update the recently logged new issue (WSN3.10: Open Content for
Publisher Registration) accordingly.
Thanks,
Sanjay
A
belated +1.
Steve Graham wrote:
Hi Sanjay: I think you understand the issue, at least as I
understand it.
It seems we are
inconsistent in BaseN on the extensibility of most of our message
exchanges.
The following
messages do not have extensibility: NotificationConsumer::Notify NotificationProducer::Subscribe NotificationProducer::SubscribeResponse NotificationProducer::GetCurrentMessage
The following messages have
extensibility: NotificationProducer::GetCurrentMessageResponse SubscriptionManager:PauseSubscription
SubscriptionManager:PauseSubscriptionResponse SubscriptionManager:ResumeSubscription
SubscriptionManager:ResumeSubscriptionResponse
So I guess a better way to consider the issue of
consistency is whether we should add extensibility to all the messages, or
whether we should remove it where it appears.
My vote would be to add extensibility to Notify,
Subscribe, SubscribeResponse and Get CurrentMessage.
sgg ++++++++ Steve Graham (919)254-0615 (T/L
444) STSM, IBM Software Group, Web services and SOA Member, IBM
Academy of Technology <Soli Deo
Gloria/> ++++++++
"Patil, Sanjay"
<sanjay.patil@sap.com> wrote on
04/25/2005 03:20:57 PM:
> Hi Steve, > > As discussed on
today's conf-call, I will be adding a new issue to our log. In that >
regard, I wanted to quickly verify my understanding of the issue
... > > Is this issue regarding the extensibility of the Publisher
Registration messages? > That is, we want to have an ability to add
open content to the > RegisterPublisherRequest and
RegisterPublisherResponse messages! However we do not > seem to have
such an extensibility for most of the other messages, for example, >
SubscribeRequest or SubscribeResponse do not allow open content (as first
class > child elements). So I am not sure what you mean by
"consistency" below. Perhaps I > have entirely misunderstood the
issue. > > Thanks, >
Sanjay > -----Original
Message----- > From: Steve Graham [mailto:sggraham@us.ibm.com] >
Sent: Wednesday, Apr 20, 2005 18:23 PM > To: wsn@lists.oasis-open.org >
Subject: [wsn] [wsn potential issue] Open content on Publisher
Registration
> > It was
pointed out to me by a colleague that there is no extensibility on
Publisher > Registration. I suggest we add one for consistency
of extensibility. Please > consider this request to raise an
issue on the WS-BrokeredNotification specification. > > sgg
> > ++++++++ > Steve Graham > (919)254-0615 (T/L
444) > STSM, IBM Software Group, Web services and SOA > Member,
IBM Academy of Technology > <Soli Deo Gloria/> >
++++++++
|