[Date Prev] | [Thread Prev] | [Thread Next] | [Date Next] -- [Date Index] | [Thread Index] | [List Home]
Subject: Re: [ciq] Initial Draft extensible Party Relationships Language (xPRL)v3.0 specification
Hi David, All your comments are valid and I have changed the specs. accordingly. I am not sure about your point 5. Thanks for your input and please let me know if you have any further feedback for me. Regards, Ram Ram Kumar wrote: > Hi David, > > Many thanks on your comments. Will look into them and come back to you. > > Regards, > > Ram > > Bruehlmeier, David wrote: >> Hi Ram, >> >> sorry for not responding earlier. I just got back from vacation. >> >> IMO, the specification is straight-forward and covers what is needed to >> represent relationships between parties. I support the decision to drop >> the somewhat "artificial" entity "group", which can very well be >> represented by the existing entity "organisation". >> >> Just a few minor notes: >> >> 1. I suggest to add the attribute "RelationshipStartReason" in symmetry >> to "RelationshipsEndReason". This might be useful e.g. when to companies >> merge, the RelationshipStartReason could be "Merger". >> >> 2. In the examples in the ciq-xprl-specs-v3.doc chapter 5.11.x, I >> suggest to use different names for RelationshipType: >> 5.11.1 "Wife-Husband" -> "Marriage" >> 5.11.2 "Subsidiary-Parent" -> "Corporation" >> 5.11.3 "Employer-Employee" -> "Employment" >> 5.11.5 "Wife-Husband" -> "Marriage" / "Sister-Brother" -> Siblings >> >> 3. I also suggest to use these terms in the documentation fields of >> xPRL.xsd and in the example xml files. >> >> 4. I don't understand nor see the necessity of the attribute >> "IsLegalEntity" in xPRL.xsd >> >> 5. In an earlier draft, I once saw the entity "review" (or similar) >> which was related to the relationship. Although it's certainly not >> crucial, I kind of liked the idea of having a formal way to document the >> reviewing of relationships. Your thoughts on that? >> >> Regards, >> Dave >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >>> -----Original Message----- >>> From: Ram Kumar [mailto:ram.kumar@oasis-open.org] Sent: Dienstag, >>> 24. Juli 2007 11:42 >>> To: ciq@lists.oasis-open.org >>> Cc: liz.kolster@ssc.govt.nz >>> Subject: [ciq] Initial Draft extensible Party Relationships Language >>> (xPRL) v3.0 specification >>> >>> Team, >>> >>> Please find enclosed the first draft of xPRL v3.0 specifications for >>> your review. >>> This package contains: >>> >>> - a draft specifications document >>> - xPRL draft schema (uses v3.0 Public Review 02 specs namel, xNL, >>> xAL, and xPIL) >>> - 12 examples demonstrating the application of xPRL >>> >>> Please review the specs., and let me know your views. Please note >>> that since we introduced >>> Relationships Language in 2001, the following were/are considered >>> out of scope for xPRL: >>> >>> * Transactional "customer/party information" such as recent >>> purchases, payment history, etc. >>> >>> * Message envelopes that carry CIQ relationship payload >>> >>> * Formatting of the CIQ represented relationship data >>> >>> * Privacy and security issues connected to exchanging and >>> storing personal information and relationships >>> >>> * Data exchange methods and procedures for party >>> relationship information >>> >>> * Messaging protocol for exchange of party relationship >>> information >>> * Validation/verification of party relationship information >>> >>> * API specifications >>> >>> * Relationships between Party and any other entity such as >>> financial/business transaction, product, service, etc >>> >>> * Privacy and access policies, access logging, tracking, and >>> control of party data and between parties >>> >>> Please provide input in the form of criticisms, suggestions, >>> feedback, etc that will help us move forward. >>> >>> Regards, >>> >>> Ram >>> >>> -- >>> >>> Ram Kumar >>> Manager - Technical Committee Development >>> OASIS >>> Post Office Box 455 >>> Billerica,MA 0821 >>> USA >>> +61 412 758 025 (Direct) >>> + 1 978 667 5115 (OASIS HQ) >>> + 1 978 667 5114 (Fax) >>> ram.kumar@oasis-open.org >>> http://www.oasis-open.org >>> "Advancing e-Business Standards Since 1993" >>> >>> >>> >> >> > -- Ram Kumar Manager - Technical Committee Development OASIS Post Office Box 455 Billerica,MA 0821 USA +61 412 758 025 (Direct) + 1 978 667 5115 (OASIS HQ) + 1 978 667 5114 (Fax) ram.kumar@oasis-open.org http://www.oasis-open.org "Advancing e-Business Standards Since 1993"
[Date Prev] | [Thread Prev] | [Thread Next] | [Date Next] -- [Date Index] | [Thread Index] | [List Home]