Comments on XAdES profile

["Nick Pope" <pope@secstan.com>]

Juan Carlos,

A few comments on what you have done so far.


2.2 lines 118-122
No need to describe verify [and updating] from arbitration.  Opens up
questions of what is arbitration and why can use this service for the long
term form.  Long term XAdES can be considered as just another predefined
XAdES structure.  Also, matches later structure.

3.1 General
For each element should indicate what server MUST or MAY support, and what
client MUST or MAY include in request.

3.1.1.1 line 166.
 Add a DSS service provider may specify other forms that it supports.

3.1.1.2	lines 172-176
Generally, I would expect the server to select the key.  MUST be supported
by server but only MAY be present in request.

Nick