RE: [wsdm] Comment on MUWS part 1 and 2

["Mitsunori Satomi" <Mitsunori.Satomi@hds.com>]

Hi, Kirk 

> From: Wilson, Kirk D [mailto:Kirk.Wilson@ca.com] 
> Mitsunori-san:
> 
> I think we need to discuss the LastUpdated problem on the conf. call.
> You're right the text doesn't say anything explicitly about 
> the requirements for using the LastUpdated attribute.  But 
> the definition of Duration attribute is defined as the 
> internval previous to the LastUpdated time, which might 
> implicitly imply that the LastUpdated attribute must be 
> provided.  A similar "implicit" implication might be read 
> into PointinTime--what was the point in time that the data 
> represents.  But you're right, given the way the spec was 
> written, LastUpdated would be just recommended.

Yes, we will discuss this issue tomorrow.

> Good catch on the <wsnt:Filter> tag.  Damn, now I'm going to 
> have to review the old WSN spec and completely revise the 
> text on pp 31-32--only to probably include the text all over 
> again the WSDM 1.1 version of the Primer.  Have you and your 
> colleagues found any other such examples.

The example which is pointed by my colleagues is only <wsnt:Filter>
issue I already described.
But I will ask them about another example which they find.

> Kirk Wilson
> Architect, Development
> Office of the CTO
> 603 823-7146

Regards,
----
Mitsunori SATOMI (mailto:Mitsunori.Satomi@hds.com)
  Director, Advanced Software Architect, SD-US
    Hitachi Data Systems Corporation
      Office: +1-408-970-4385 / Fax: +1-408-327-3351

> -----Original Message-----
> From: Mitsunori Satomi [mailto:Mitsunori.Satomi@hds.com]
> Sent: Tuesday, February 21, 2006 10:53 PM
> To: wsdm@lists.oasis-open.org
> Subject: [wsdm] Comment on MUWS part 1 and 2
> 
> Hi,
> 
> I found some typos and comment in the spec documents.
> 
> 1. MUWS Part1 (KDW wsdm-muws-part1-1[1][1][1].0-vjb-tws-me.doc)
>  - P5L134 "a group of properties-operations," should be "a 
> group of properties, operations,"
> 
> 2. MUWS Part2 (KDW wsdm-muws-part2-1[1][1].0-vjb-changesaccepted.doc)
>  - P29L1135 "/muws1:ResourceID" should be "/muws1:ResourceId".
> 
> 3. MUWS Primer (wd-wsdm-primer-muws-wd_final.doc)
>  - P40L1896 This table shows "LastUpdated" attribute is 
> "REQUIRED" if TimeScope="Interval" or "PointInTime".
>                    But MUWS spec Part2 does not describe 
> anything about this attribute is required or not.
>                    So IMHO, I suggest that we should change 
> these two columns from "REQUIRED"(checked mark) to "recommended".
> 
> And my colleagues in Japan are worried about the consistency 
> between Primer documents and other related specs (WSRF, WSN 
> and WS-Addressing).
> For example, at the MOWS Primer document P13L566, this sample 
> XML text use <wsnt:Filter> tag, but I think that WSN Jun. 
> 2004 version spec doesn't have such XML tag.
> (<wsnt:Filter> is a tag of new version of WSN).
> 
> IMHO after WSDM 1.1 is adopted, we should update the both 
> Primer documents which have consistency with the related 
> specifications, or we should synchronize the Primer and MUWS 
> / MOWS spec. in the next version (WSDM 2.0?).
>  
> I am so sorry for sending our comments later.
> ----
> Mitsunori SATOMI (mailto:Mitsunori.Satomi@hds.com)
>   Director, Advanced Software Architect, SD-US
>     Hitachi Data Systems Corporation
>       Office: +1-408-970-4385 / Fax: +1-408-327-3351
> 
> 
> ---------------------------------------------------------------------
> To unsubscribe from this mail list, you must leave the OASIS 
> TC that generates this mail.  You may a link to this group 
> and all your TCs in OASIS
> at:
> https://www.oasis-open.org/apps/org/workgroup/portal/my_workgr
> oups.php 
> 
> 
>