Re: [docbook] Simpified DocBook

[Dave Pawson <davep@dpawson.co.uk>]

Thomas Schraitle wrote:

> I know, but I mean another issue. :) My idea was to validate your RNC file 
> against the RELAX NG schema. I was mislead by the impression that it is 
> only possible with the RNG format. However, it seems oXygen can also 
> validate RNC files.

Yes, I think Oxygen uses jing.

> 
> Apart from this I get different results between msv and jing on one side 
> and oXygen on the other side. Even with the errors msv and jing don't 
> complain but oXygen did. To discover these errors, it was not possible 
> with RNC, but with the RNG format. Maybe I did something wrong, but from 
> my impressions all should give the same results. 


In a perfect world, yes...

I don't know how good the relax ng schema is.
Anyone else?

I think I would rather trust jing than msv, but I have no
evidence to say it is better (or worse).



regards

-- 
Dave Pawson
XSLT XSL-FO FAQ.
http://www.dpawson.co.uk